Mathieu Darche's first foray into free agency as the New York Islanders' General Manager can be described as a steady, if not spectacular, start. Tasked with managing all aspects of the team's hockey operations, Darche, who was appointed GM on May 23, 2025, made a series of moves that prioritized depth and flexibility, signaling a commitment to both short-term competitiveness and long-term prospect development.

Darche's approach to free agency reflected a clear vision: avoid long-term commitments that could hinder the team's future while addressing immediate needs. A key example of this strategy was the signing of Jonathan Drouin, a former first-round pick, to a two-year, $8 million contract. Drouin, who has shown flashes of brilliance but struggled with consistency, is expected to bolster the Islanders' top-six forward group and improve their anemic power play. Darche highlighted Drouin's playmaking ability and versatility as key assets, noting that he can play both wing and center, providing Head Coach Patrick Roy with more lineup options.

In addition to Drouin, Darche added goaltending depth by signing David Rittich to a one-year deal. Rittich, a veteran netminder, is expected to provide insurance behind Ilya Sorokin, especially with Semyon Varlamov's health situation uncertain. This move addresses a potential vulnerability in the Islanders' depth chart without committing significant resources long-term.

Darche also focused on solidifying the Islanders' blue line, re-signing Tony DeAngelo to a one-year, $1.75 million contract. DeAngelo, who was acquired mid-season last year, proved to be a valuable addition to the team's power play and overall defensive structure. The Islanders also added Ethan Bear on a one-year deal.

Furthermore, Darche extended Simon Holmstrom's contract for two years at $3.63 million AAV. This move allows the Islanders to further evaluate Holmstrom's potential while maintaining flexibility for future roster decisions.

One of Darche's most significant moves prior to free agency was signing defenseman Alexander Romanov to an eight-year contract extension. This long-term commitment underscores the Islanders' belief in Romanov as a key building block for the team's future.

While Darche's moves were not splashy, they were strategic and addressed specific needs. By prioritizing short-term deals and depth additions, Darche has positioned the Islanders to compete in the present while maintaining the flexibility to integrate young prospects into the lineup in the coming years. This approach represents a departure from the Islanders' previous management style, which often favored veteran players and longer-term contracts.

Overall, Mathieu Darche's first free agency as GM was a success. He addressed key areas of need, added depth to the roster, and maintained financial flexibility for the future. While the Islanders may not have made any blockbuster signings, Darche's measured approach has set the team up for a competitive season and a promising future.