The Edmonton Oilers' decision to sign Andrew Mangiapane over Brock Boeser in the recent free agency period appears to be a savvy move that addresses the team's needs while maintaining financial flexibility. While both players bring offensive capabilities, Mangiapane's overall package seems to be a better fit for the Oilers at this juncture.

Reports indicate the Oilers expressed interest in Boeser, but any potential offer was contingent on offloading existing salary. Ultimately, the Oilers signed Mangiapane to a contract that provides excellent value. Some reports suggest the Oilers were considering offering Boeser a long-term deal in the $6 million range or a short-term deal at $7.5 million.

Boeser ultimately re-signed with the Vancouver Canucks for a reported seven-year deal. While Boeser is known for his scoring touch, particularly his shot, he may not be the ideal complementary player the Oilers need. Edmonton needs players who can contribute in multiple facets of the game and provide a spark in various situations.

Mangiapane brings a different dimension to the Oilers. He is known for his relentless work ethic, forechecking ability, and willingness to play a gritty, two-way game. He also contributes on the penalty kill. These are valuable assets that can complement the Oilers' star players, Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. Mangiapane has expressed his confidence that he would fit in well on one of the first two lines.

Financially, Mangiapane's contract is a more palatable option for the Oilers. With limited cap space, the Oilers needed to be prudent with their spending. Mangiapane's deal allows them to add a valuable player without significantly hindering their ability to make other moves. Some reports indicate Mangiapane brings better than 50 percent of what Boeser brings at twice the price.

The Oilers lost some grit with the departure of Evander Kane and Corey Perry. Mangiapane will adequately replace that lost grit. Ultimately, the Oilers' decision to sign Mangiapane over Boeser reflects a strategic approach to team building. While Boeser's offensive capabilities are undeniable, Mangiapane's versatility, work ethic, and cost-effectiveness make him a more suitable fit for the Oilers' current needs and long-term goals. This signing addresses key areas of concern for the team while maintaining financial flexibility, positioning the Oilers for continued success.