The Edmonton Oilers' goaltending situation, specifically the performance of Stuart Skinner, has been a major talking point for fans and analysts. After two consecutive seasons ending in Stanley Cup Finals losses, many expected the Oilers to address their goaltending. However, the team has largely stood pat, raising concerns about their chances of making another deep playoff run.

Skinner's Performance in 2024-25

In the 2024-25 regular season, Stuart Skinner played in 51 games, recording a 26-18-4 record. His goals-against average (GAA) was 2.81, and his save percentage (SV%) was .896. While these numbers aren't alarming, they also don't place him among the league's elite goalies. In his last 10 games, Skinner posted a 5-4-0 record with a 2.97 GAA and a .892 SV%.

Playoff Struggles

Skinner's playoff performance has been a significant area of concern. In the 2025 playoffs, he started 15 games, winning 7, with a 2.99 GAA and an .889 SV%. These numbers indicate a decline in performance compared to his regular-season stats. He allowed four or more goals in a game six times during the 2025 playoffs. Some analysts have pointed out "beachball goals" that have eroded fan confidence. There was even a point where Skinner yielded his duties to Calvin Pickard, then temporarily took it back, only to be replaced again during the Stanley Cup Finals.

Lack of Consistency

One of the main issues with Skinner's game is his consistency. He can have stretches of excellent play, such as his strong performance in the Dallas series during the 2025 playoffs, where he recorded back-to-back shutouts. However, he also has periods of struggle, allowing soft goals and failing to make key saves at critical moments. This inconsistency makes it difficult for the team to rely on him, and it can impact their confidence in front of him.

Oilers' Options

The Oilers' management has faced criticism for not addressing the goaltending situation more aggressively. With limited cap space, making a significant upgrade in goal is challenging. The team did make a change to the goalie coach this summer, hoping that a new voice and approach can help Skinner improve his consistency and performance.

Some have proposed potential trade scenarios, such as acquiring Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen from the Buffalo Sabres, potentially involving Skinner in the deal. However, such a move would carry its own risks, as Luukkonen is unproven in the playoffs. Other options, like John Gibson, have already been traded to other teams.

The Path Forward

As it stands, the Oilers appear poised to start the 2025-26 season with Stuart Skinner as their primary goalie, backed up by Calvin Pickard. Whether this is the right decision remains to be seen. Skinner has shown flashes of brilliance and has the potential to be a top-tier netminder. However, he needs to find more consistency and elevate his game in high-pressure situations. If he can do that, the Oilers will be in a much better position to contend for the Stanley Cup. If not, the team may need to explore other options during the season or in the next offseason.