Guwahati, India – Team India is facing severe backlash from experts and fans alike after suffering a devastating 408-run defeat against South Africa in the second Test at Guwahati, resulting in a 2-0 series whitewash. This loss marks South Africa's first Test series win in India in 25 years and India's heaviest Test defeat at home by runs, surpassing their previous 342-run defeat against Australia in 2004. The dismal performance has ignited a storm of criticism directed towards head coach Gautam Gambhir and chief selector Ajit Agarkar, with many calling for their removal.
The defeat in Guwahati exposed glaring weaknesses in India's batting lineup, as they were bundled out for a mere 140 while chasing an improbable target of 549. Only Ravindra Jadeja offered some resistance with a score of 54. Seasoned off-spinner Simon Harmer proved to be the architect of India's downfall, claiming a sensational six-wicket haul to finish with nine wickets in the match.
The first Test in Kolkata also saw India succumb to a 30-run defeat on a challenging pitch at Eden Gardens. Across the four innings of the series, the Indian team managed to cross the 200-run mark only once, highlighting their struggles with the bat.
Former players and coaches have been vocal in their criticism of the team's performance and the decisions made by the team management. Venkatesh Prasad, a former India pacer, questioned the clarity in team selection and the over-tactical approach. He argued that India can no longer be considered a top Test side with such planning. Mohammed Shami's coach, Laxmi Ratan Shukla, also expressed his concerns about the team's composition, stating that India was fielding too many all-rounders and not enough specialist batters.
The selection of Washington Sundar at No. 3 in the first Test, ahead of a specialist batter like Sai Sudharsan, drew heavy criticism. Fans and analysts have also questioned Agarkar's decision to exclude Shreyas Iyer from the BCCI central contract, despite his strong performances. Some accuse Agarkar of prioritizing IPL stars over proven domestic players, a strategy they believe is unsuitable for Test cricket.
Interim captain Rishabh Pant didn't hold back, admitting the team needed to improve and that they failed to capitalize on crucial moments. He stressed the importance of determination and extra effort, whether playing at home or away.
The series loss has sparked a significant backlash on social media, with fans demanding accountability and calling for immediate changes in the team management. The pressure is mounting on Gautam Gambhir and Ajit Agarkar to address the team's shortcomings and restore India's dominance in Test cricket. Some fans are more frustrated with Ajit Agarkar than with Gautam Gambhir and are demanding changes in the selection committee.
This marks the first time in 66 years that India has lost five home Tests in the span of seven games. The repeated failures have raised questions about the team's ability to adapt, strategically plan selections, and build partnerships under pressure. The team's journey towards the 2027 World Test Championship final has become significantly more challenging.
