Following a disappointing 0-2 Test series loss to South Africa, India is gearing up for a three-match ODI series against the Proteas, commencing on November 30th. With Shubman Gill sidelined due to a neck injury and Shreyas Iyer also out, the Indian team management faces a crucial decision: who will partner Rohit Sharma at the top of the order?. The contenders are Ruturaj Gaikwad and Yashasvi Jaiswal. While both are talented and deserving, Gaikwad appears to have a slight edge in this selection race. KL Rahul will lead the side in the absence of Gill and Iyer.
Gaikwad's Recent Form and Experience
Ruturaj Gaikwad has been in impressive form, particularly in the India A series against South Africa A. He showcased his ability to score runs consistently, which strengthens his case for opening the innings. Gaikwad's List A record is also noteworthy. He has amassed 4534 runs in 89 List A matches, averaging an impressive 57.39. This includes 17 centuries and 18 half-centuries. In contrast, Jaiswal has 1526 runs in 33 List A matches, averaging 52.62.
Gaikwad has featured in 6 ODIs, scoring 115 runs, with a highest score of 71. Four of those matches saw him opening the innings, and 98 of his 115 ODI runs have come while batting at the top. While these numbers aren't overwhelming, they showcase his experience in the format. He last played an ODI in December 2023.
Jaiswal's Explosive Potential
Yashasvi Jaiswal is an explosive left-handed batsman who has already made a mark in Test cricket. However, his ODI experience is limited. Jaiswal has played only one ODI, scoring 15 runs against England in February 2025. Despite his limited ODI experience, Jaiswal's aggressive style of play and his left-handedness could be seen as an advantage. A left-right combination at the top, with Rohit Sharma, could disrupt the South African bowling attack.
The Deciding Factors
Several factors tilt the balance in Gaikwad's favor. His recent form in the India A series demonstrates his readiness for international cricket. Gaikwad's experience in List A cricket and his familiarity with the ODI format give him an edge over Jaiswal, who is still relatively new to this format. The team management might also consider Gaikwad as a potential number 4, given Shreyas Iyer's injury. This could allow Jaiswal to open with Rohit, but recent reports suggest Gaikwad is being considered for the number 4 position.
Ultimately, the decision hinges on India's strategy for the series and their long-term plans. If the team prioritizes a stable and experienced opener, Gaikwad is the likely choice. If they are looking for a more aggressive option with a left-right combination, Jaiswal might get the nod.
Series Details
The ODI series will be played across three venues: Ranchi (November 30), Raipur (December 3), and Visakhapatnam (December 6). All matches are scheduled to begin at 1:30 PM IST. The series will be broadcast on the Star Sports Network and streamed on Jio Hotstar. Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma are expected to play pivotal roles in the series. The ODI series presents an opportunity for India to bounce back after the Test series defeat and to test their bench strength in preparation for future tournaments.
