The Edmonton Oilers' goaltending situation is under intense scrutiny, with speculation mounting about a potential trade to shake things up. The team's inconsistent performance in net has fueled rumors of a "lateral move," even if it doesn't represent a significant upgrade, to try and spark a change in the team's dynamic.
For months, the Oilers have publicly supported Stuart Skinner, citing his affordable $2.6 million cap hit as a valuable asset for a team with limited financial flexibility. The organization initially believed they possessed two capable goaltenders in Skinner and Calvin Pickard at a reasonable price. However, their combined performance this season has fallen short of expectations, failing to consistently provide the stability needed to propel the Oilers to a winning record and a deep playoff run.
After a recent 8-3 loss to the Dallas Stars where Skinner allowed four goals on eight shots in the first period, the situation appears to have reached a critical point. Some insiders suggest that the Oilers are now contemplating whether it's best for both the team and Skinner to part ways. TSN's Ryan Rishaug added to the speculation, hinting that Skinner might not finish the season in Edmonton.
Several names have emerged as potential trade targets for the Oilers. Tristan Jarry of the Pittsburgh Penguins has been repeatedly mentioned. Jarry, who has ties to Edmonton from his time with the Oil Kings, is reportedly having a strong season after a challenging 2024-25. Other goalies linked to the Oilers include Jordan Binnington of the St. Louis Blues and Laurent Brossoit of the Chicago Blackhawks.
General Manager Stan Bowman acknowledged the team's struggles, stating that the goaltending has been "average" but also emphasized that the issues aren't solely limited to Skinner and Pickard. He believes the team as a whole isn't "clicking" and that improvements are needed across all positions.
The Oilers' struggles are reflected in their current statistics. They rank 28th in the NHL in goals-against per game (3.47) and 18th in goals-for per game (3.06). Skinner has a 8-6-3 record with an .878 save percentage and a 3.00 goals-against average in 17 appearances this season. Pickard's numbers are even less encouraging, with a 2-3-2 record, an .847 save percentage, and a 4.04 goals-against average.
While Connor McDavid publicly expressed confidence in the team's ability to turn things around, he also acknowledged that it's difficult for goalies to perform well when the team in front of them isn't playing up to their standards.
The Oilers' potential pursuit of a goaltender like Jarry is not without its risks. Jarry's performance has been inconsistent throughout his career, and he struggled significantly last season, even spending time in the AHL. Acquiring Jarry would also mean taking on the remaining term of his contract, which could be a concern if he doesn't perform well in Edmonton.
Despite the risks, the Oilers' desperation to improve their goaltending situation may force them to make a move. The pressure is mounting, and the team needs to find a way to stabilize their play in net if they hope to contend for a playoff spot and keep Connor McDavid in Edmonton long term.
