The Edmonton Oilers' ongoing struggles in the net have fueled speculation about a potential goalie trade as the deadline approaches, but concerns linger that a hasty move could backfire, echoing the issues experienced with defenseman John Klingberg.
Edmonton's goaltending has been a major talking point this season, with both Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard failing to provide the consistency needed for a team with Stanley Cup aspirations. Skinner, who led the Oilers to within one win of the Cup last season, has struggled to replicate that form, posting a .885 save percentage through 19 games. Pickard has fared even worse, with an .847 save percentage in nine appearances.
As a result, the Oilers have been linked to several goalies in trade rumors, including Tristan Jarry of the Pittsburgh Penguins and Jordan Binnington of the St. Louis Blues. However, NHL insider Elliotte Friedman has reported that the Oilers are hesitant to make a "lateral move" and will only pursue a trade if they are convinced it's a significant upgrade. This reluctance stems from the Oilers' experience with Klingberg earlier in the year.
In January 2025, the Oilers signed Klingberg to a one-year deal hoping to add offensive support from the blue line. Klingberg, a veteran defenseman with a history of offensive production, had been sidelined for over a year due to injury. The move was seen as a low-risk gamble, but it ultimately didn't pay off. Klingberg struggled to find his form, appearing in just 11 games and recording one goal and four points before being placed on long-term injured reserve (LTIR).
Klingberg's injury history and inability to regain his previous level of play serve as a cautionary tale for the Oilers as they consider a goalie trade. The team is wary of acquiring a goalie with a questionable injury history or one whose performance has declined in recent years. The Oilers are prioritizing consistency and health in their search for a goaltending upgrade.
Several factors complicate the Oilers' search for a goalie. The trade market for goalies is always unpredictable. Few teams are willing to part with their starting goalies, and those who are available often come with significant question marks. The Oilers also need to consider the salary cap implications of acquiring a new goalie. Skinner's $2.6 million cap hit is relatively affordable, and taking on a larger salary could force the Oilers to make other difficult roster decisions.
Despite the challenges, the Oilers recognize the need to address their goaltending situation if they hope to contend for the Stanley Cup. The team is carefully evaluating its options and is determined to avoid a repeat of the Klingberg situation, where a seemingly low-risk move ultimately backfired. The Oilers are willing to be patient and wait for the right opportunity to acquire a goalie who can provide a significant upgrade in net.
