Play of Oilers’ Top Goalie Targets Going in Opposite Directions
As the Edmonton Oilers navigate a challenging 2025-26 season, their goaltending situation remains a primary concern, prompting speculation and rumors about potential acquisitions. While the team evaluates its options, the trajectories of some rumored targets appear to be diverging, adding another layer of complexity to the Oilers' decision-making process.
Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard have not provided the consistent, high-caliber performance required for a team with Stanley Cup aspirations. Recent lopsided losses have only intensified the pressure on the Oilers' front office to find a solution before their season spirals further. The search for a reliable netminder has led to the consideration of several potential trade targets, but according to NHL insider Elliotte Friedman, the Oilers are unwilling to make a lateral move in net.
One name frequently linked to the Oilers is Jordan Binnington of the St. Louis Blues. Despite a somewhat rocky start to the 2025-26 campaign, Binnington's value is currently on the upswing, particularly after praise from Hall of Fame Goalie Martin Brodeur. Brodeur emphasized that evaluating a goalie requires looking at the context, not just the standings. He noted that selectors prioritize instincts, decision-making, and the ability to remain calm under pressure rather than simple win-loss records. Brodeur's comments bolster the narrative that Binnington elevates his play when the stakes are highest. His performance for Canada in overtime and gold-medal situations demonstrated a clutch gene that could be priceless for Edmonton in the playoffs. The Oilers would be betting on that experience, the ability to shut the door when it matters most, rather than his uneven regular-season statistics.
Conversely, Tristan Jarry of the Pittsburgh Penguins, another goalie mentioned in connection with the Oilers, seems to be facing headwinds. While Jarry has demonstrated solid performance with a 5-2-0 record, a 2.60 goals-against average and a .911 save percentage in seven games this season, the Penguins having a total of four goalies in their system may make them open to a trade if the right offer arises. However, it seems like neither goalie is a risk the Oilers are willing to take.
Other names previously linked to the Oilers include St. Louis Blues' Jordan Binnington, Nashville Predators' Juuse Saros, New York Rangers' Jonathan Quick, and Toronto Maple Leafs' Anthony Stolarz. TSN analyst Marc Denis has even suggested Nashville Predators star Juuse Saros as Edmonton's "dream target".
Ultimately, the Edmonton Oilers face a critical decision. They must weigh the potential risks and rewards of acquiring a new goaltender against the possibility of internal improvement. With the play of potential targets like Binnington and Jarry heading in different directions, the Oilers' front office has a complex puzzle to solve as they strive to solidify their position as a true contender.
