The Edmonton Oilers' quest for goaltending stability has been a persistent storyline, and the latest chapter involves potential interest in St. Louis Blues' netminder Jordan Binnington. While speculation of a trade involving Binnington and Oilers' goalie Stuart Skinner has circulated, a recent report suggests a significant hurdle: Edmonton might be on Binnington's no-trade list.
According to Andy Strickland on The Cam and Strick Podcast, Binnington's no-trade clause could complicate any potential deal with the Oilers. If accurate, this revelation shifts the dynamic, requiring Binnington's approval for any trade to Edmonton. This changes the Oilers' position from an aggressive suitor to a team that must wait for Binnington's decision.
Despite the potential roadblock, the idea of Binnington joining the Oilers isn't without merit. The Oilers are in a championship window and are seeking a reliable goalie. Binnington brings a Stanley Cup pedigree and a reputation for performing well under pressure. For the Blues, who are potentially retooling, trading Binnington, who has term remaining on his contract, could bring back valuable assets.
However, Binnington's recent performance has been inconsistent. In a December 1st game against the Anaheim Ducks, he was pulled after allowing two goals on five shots, adding fuel to questions about his reliability. Skinner, on the other hand, delivered a shutout performance against the Seattle Kraken, further complicating the Oilers' decision.
The rumored trade also faces financial complexities. Binnington carries a $6 million cap hit through next season, while Skinner's contract is expiring. The Oilers would likely need to include additional assets to offset the difference if they want the Blues to take on part of Binnington's contract.
Some analysts have speculated that the Oilers' interest in Binnington might also involve acquiring a defenseman from the Blues. However, the Blues' defensive roster presents challenges, with players like Colton Parayko having full no-trade clauses and significant cap hits.
Ultimately, whether a deal materializes remains uncertain. The presence of a no-trade list adds a layer of complexity, but doesn't necessarily kill the potential for a trade. The Oilers' desperation for goaltending stability, combined with the Blues' potential willingness to move Binnington, could keep negotiations alive. It is also important to consider that these remain speculations and no formal negotiations have been confirmed.
