MacKinnon's Overtime Magic Sparks Best Player Debate

NEW YORK - Nathan MacKinnon etched his name deeper into the NHL's narrative with a dazzling overtime goal against the New York Rangers, propelling the Colorado Avalanche to a 3-2 victory. The electrifying performance has reignited the debate: Is MacKinnon now the league's best player, surpassing Connor McDavid?.

MacKinnon's game-winning goal showcased his exceptional skill and determination. Collecting a pass from Cale Makar, he navigated through a pair of Rangers defenders before lifting a backhand shot over Igor Shesterkin's glove and into the top corner. This marked his league-leading 24th goal of the season. Earlier in the game, MacKinnon also batted in a rebound, further underscoring his offensive prowess.

"It wasn't just the overtime heroics that defined MacKinnon's night," one analyst noted. "He was in the right place at the right time.". His consistent performance and leadership are propelling Colorado's championship ambitions.

The Avalanche are currently dominating the NHL standings, a testament to MacKinnon's impact. The team has an impressive 19-1-6 record to start the season. MacKinnon's individual stats are equally impressive. Through 27 games, he has amassed 46 points.

"MacKinnon is a man on a mission right now," said one observer, "and it's gotten to a point where teams around the NHL have no chance of stopping him".

The question of whether MacKinnon has surpassed McDavid is complex. McDavid has long been considered the gold standard, boasting multiple Hart Trophies and scoring titles. However, MacKinnon's recent performances and the Avalanche's team success are making the conversation increasingly compelling.

In a recent NHL.com poll, a majority of respondents selected MacKinnon as the better player as of November 29, 2025. This outcome challenges McDavid's long-standing dominance. MacKinnon finished with 70 points in the poll, while McDavid was fourth with 28 points.

"With 56 games left, the story of this year's MVP will be written in real time and nothing feels predetermined," a Times of India report stated. "Right now, Nathan MacKinnon isn't just challenging McDavid's throne. He may be taking it.".

Some argue that MacKinnon's edge in goal scoring this season sets him apart. Others point to his consistency and discipline as key factors. "He's consistent with everything he does all the time, professionally at least," Avalanche coach Jared Bednar said. "I think those habits and that discipline leads to consistency.".

Despite MacKinnon's brilliance, McDavid remains a formidable force. He has a track record of exceptional offensive production and highlight-reel plays. McDavid has three Hart Trophies, compared to MacKinnon's one.

Ultimately, the debate over who is the better player is subjective. Both MacKinnon and McDavid possess unique skills and attributes. MacKinnon's recent overtime heroics and his team's success have undoubtedly elevated him into the conversation. As the season progresses, the two superstars will continue to be compared, and their performances will shape the narrative of the NHL's best player debate.