The San Jose Sharks are heading into the 2025 NHL Entry Draft with a unique opportunity to reshape their future. Armed with the second overall pick and the 30th overall pick, the Sharks have a chance to add high-end talent to both their forward and defensive prospect pools. While the specific players they target will depend on how the draft unfolds, the general consensus is that addressing needs on both sides of the ice is paramount for the Sharks' long-term success.
With the second overall pick, the Sharks will likely be choosing between a few highly touted prospects. Many mock drafts have the New York Islanders selecting defenseman Matthew Schaefer first overall, leaving the Sharks to choose from forwards like Michael Misa and James Hagens. While the Sharks have already added promising young forwards like Will Smith and Macklin Celebrini to the system, they finished last in the league in goals scored this past season, highlighting the need for more offensive firepower. Selecting Misa, who some scouts believe is the most NHL-ready player in the draft, could provide an immediate boost to the Sharks' scoring depth. Hagens is another compelling option, as his high-end skill and hockey sense could make him a top-line player in the future.
However, if Schaefer is somehow available at pick number two, the Sharks should sprint to the podium to select him. Most analysts agree that San Jose's greatest organizational need is on defense, and Schaefer is considered the best defenseman in this draft class. The Erie Otters standout is a strong skater with excellent offensive instincts and the potential to develop into a top-pairing NHL defenseman.
Regardless of whether they go with a forward or defenseman at pick number two, the Sharks will have another chance to add a valuable prospect at pick number 30. With this pick, the Sharks should strongly consider drafting a defenseman to bolster their defensive depth. Henry Brzustewicz is a right-shot defenseman who could be available around this spot. Some other potential defensive targets at pick 30 include Kashawn Aitcheson, Jackson Smith, and Cameron Reid.
Of course, the Sharks could also opt to trade one or both of their first-round picks to move up or down in the draft order or acquire additional assets. General Manager Mike Grier has shown a willingness to be aggressive in the trade market, and he could look to package the 30th overall pick with other assets to move up into the top 20. Alternatively, if the Sharks are not sold on any of the players available at pick number two, they could trade down and acquire additional draft picks or prospects.
Ultimately, the Sharks' success in the 2025 NHL Draft will depend on their ability to identify and select players who fit their long-term vision for the team. By taking one forward and one defenseman in the first round, the Sharks can address their needs on both sides of the ice and continue to build a strong foundation for the future.
