Shane Pinto's future with the Ottawa Senators is a topic of much discussion as he approaches eligibility for a contract extension this summer. Pinto, currently earning $3.75 million with one year remaining on his contract, has expressed his desire to stay in Ottawa long-term, stating, "Yeah, obviously, I love being here, love the boys. We're building something special. And I wouldn't be opposed to staying here for a long time." However, the Senators face a crucial decision: should they commit to Pinto with a long-term deal, or opt for a shorter "bridge" contract?

Several factors weigh in favor of a long-term commitment. At 24 years old, Pinto is considered a core player with a steadily growing resume. In the 2024-25 season, he achieved career highs in goals (21) and points (37). He brings a valuable two-way presence to the team, contributing on both offense and defense. His versatility is evident in his ability to play in all situations, including special teams. Moreover, Pinto's performance at the 2025 IIHF World Championship, where he recorded 10 points in seven games for Team USA, further solidified his potential and value.

Committing to Pinto long-term would provide stability and solidify the Senators' depth at the center position. While Tim Stützle and Dylan Cozens are currently seen as the top two centers, Pinto provides excellent insurance and a potential plan B if Cozens doesn't live up to expectations. He has demonstrated the ability to elevate his game and embrace different roles, making him a valuable asset to the team's overall success.

However, the Senators also have to consider potential risks. Pinto's NHL career has been marked by some inconsistency, with injuries and a suspension causing him to miss a significant number of games. There is some internal debate if Pinto's ceiling is that of a third-line defensive center who contributes secondary offense. Pinto's contract negotiations will also have to be carefully managed. Pinto will be eligible to sign a contract extension on July 1, his play at the 2025 IIHF World Championship is helping raise his game to earn a nice pay from the Senators. One projection estimates a potential five-year contract could be in the range of $5.5 - 6.25 million per year.

Ultimately, the decision to commit long-term to Shane Pinto hinges on the Ottawa Senators' vision for the team's future. If they believe Pinto has the potential to develop into a top-six forward and a key contributor to their offensive output, then a long-term contract would be a worthwhile investment. However, if they see him primarily as a reliable third-line center, they may prefer a shorter-term deal to assess his continued development and fit within the team's evolving structure. With Pinto expressing his desire to stay in Ottawa, the Senators have an opportunity to secure a valuable player for years to come. The key will be finding a contract that reflects his current value while also acknowledging his potential for future growth.