The question of whether Karun Nair and Sai Sudharsan have done enough to cement their places in the Indian cricket team is a complex one, particularly when viewed through the lens of their recent performances and the opportunities that lie ahead. Both batsmen have been in and out of the squad, facing stiff competition for a spot in the middle order.
Karun Nair's Comeback and Challenges
Karun Nair's return to the Test squad after a long hiatus was a heartening story, given his previous triple century. However, his performance in the recent Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy series against England has been a subject of scrutiny. Nair managed 205 runs at an average of 25.62, with only one half-century. Former Indian cricketer Irfan Pathan rated Nair's performance 4 out of 10, pointing out his inability to capitalize on starts. Pathan highlighted the Lord's Test as a missed opportunity where Nair could have won the match for India. Despite looking comfortable initially, he often got out before converting his starts into substantial scores. A finger injury has also sidelined Nair, adding to his challenges. While there is hope for his comeback, he will need to prove himself again in domestic cricket.
Sai Sudharsan's Promising Potential
In contrast, Sai Sudharsan is seen as a player with considerable potential. Pathan gave Sudharsan a rating of 5 out of 10, suggesting that he could have performed better if given more consistent opportunities. Sudharsan's recent IPL form has been impressive, with a fifty against Kolkata Knight Riders and consistent performances in other matches. He has also been a top performer in the IPL 2025, even toppling Nicholas Pooran for the Orange Cap. His overall IPL record shows an average of 49.81 and a strike rate of 145.89. Sudharsan is also likely to be considered for the Asia Cup 2025 squad.
The Road Ahead
Looking ahead, both Nair and Sudharsan face different paths. Nair needs to recover from his injury and perform consistently in domestic cricket to regain the selectors' attention. Sudharsan, on the other hand, has the opportunity to showcase his skills in the Asia Cup 2025 and potentially cement his place in the T20I squad.
The Indian team is undergoing a transition, with Shubman Gill leading the Test side. The middle order needs strengthening, and while Nair and Sudharsan have shown glimpses of their abilities, they need to be more consistent. The upcoming Duleep Trophy 2025 will be a crucial tournament for players to prove their mettle.
Ultimately, whether Nair and Sudharsan have done enough depends on their future performances and their ability to seize opportunities. While Nair has the experience, Sudharsan has youth and potential on his side. Only time will tell if they can solidify their positions in the Indian cricket team.
