The Frederik Andersen trade, initially executed in 2016 when the Toronto Maple Leafs acquired the goaltender from the Anaheim Ducks, has been a topic of recurring discussion among hockey analysts and fans alike. Recent developments in the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs, where Andersen is showcasing exceptional form with the Carolina Hurricanes, have brought renewed attention to the long-term implications and overall success of that trade.
Back in 2016, Toronto sent Anaheim their 2016 first-round pick (30th overall) and a 2017 second-round pick. Anaheim used these picks to select Sam Steel and Max Comtois, respectively. At the time, Anaheim was ready to move forward with John Gibson as their long-term goalie. Toronto, on the other hand, was looking for a reliable number-one goalie.
Andersen's tenure with the Maple Leafs spanned five seasons, during which he solidified himself as their starting goaltender. He consistently delivered solid regular-season performances, amassing a record of 149-74-36 with a .914 save percentage. However, the team's inability to translate regular-season success into deep playoff runs raised questions about Andersen's ability to perform under pressure in crucial postseason games.
After his time in Toronto, Andersen signed with the Carolina Hurricanes. Since joining the Hurricanes in the 2021-22 season, when healthy, Andersen has been remarkably consistent. He has recorded 100 wins, 10 shutouts, and a .915 save percentage in regular season and playoff games combined. He has also persevered through injuries and a health concern, being limited to 16 games last regular season due to a blood-clotting issue.
In the 2025 playoffs, Andersen's performance has been nothing short of stellar. As of May 16, 2025, he boasts a .937 save percentage and has been instrumental in the Hurricanes' journey to the Eastern Conference Final. His dominance in high-danger situations is particularly noteworthy, leading all NHL goalies in high-danger save percentage (.923) this postseason. According to NHL EDGE IQ, Andersen also leads the league in save percentage against shots attempted off the cycle (.968).
Andersen's impressive play has drawn high praise from teammates and analysts alike. Defenseman Shayne Gostisbehere lauded Andersen as the "backbone of our team" throughout the playoffs. Experts have noted that Andersen's stellar numbers might even be better than they appear, given the Hurricanes' exceptional ability to limit shots against.
Moreover, Andersen's current contract with the Hurricanes, set at a bargain of approximately $3.5 million (including performance bonuses), is viewed as a significant asset for the team. His outstanding performance relative to his cap hit underscores the value he brings to the Hurricanes, especially considering the importance of strong goaltending in playoff success.
Looking back, the trade can be viewed as beneficial for both sides. The Maple Leafs received several years of dependable goaltending from Andersen. The Ducks drafted Sam Steel and Max Comtois, both of whom became NHL players, though neither is still with the organization. Now, with Andersen leading the Hurricanes deep into the playoffs, and signed to a team-friendly deal, the trade continues to be a fascinating case study in NHL player movement.
