The USMNT's goalkeeping situation has become a major talking point heading into the 2025 Gold Cup. For years, the position seemed locked down by Matt Turner. However, a lack of consistent playing time at the club level combined with the emergence of Matt Freese has created a genuine debate.

Head coach Mauricio Pochettino acknowledged the situation, highlighting Turner's experience while also noting his recent lack of playing time. Pochettino stated that this is a good opportunity to relieve some pressure from Turner and allow another goalkeeper to compete for a spot in the World Cup roster. He emphasized that Freese deserved the opportunity due to his strong performances at the club level and in his recent appearances for the national team.

Freese, the 26-year-old New York City FC goalkeeper, has indeed been making a strong case for himself. He made his USMNT debut in a friendly against Türkiye, followed by starting in the Gold Cup opener against Trinidad and Tobago, a match the USMNT won 5-0. Although Trinidad and Tobago didn't pose a constant threat, Freese did make crucial saves, proving his readiness for the starting role.

Turner, on the other hand, has been the USMNT's preferred choice since 2021. He backstopped the team during the 2021 Gold Cup and played a key role in World Cup qualifying. However, since moving to Europe, first with Arsenal and then Nottingham Forest, his playing time has been sporadic. A recent loan to Crystal Palace saw him stuck behind Dean Henderson, further limiting his opportunities.

The statistics also favor Freese at the moment. In the previous MLS season, he recorded an impressive 73.4% save percentage and prevented nearly nine goals, placing him among the league's best. He has continued that form this season with a 73.7% save percentage and six clean sheets already.

Pochettino's decision to start Freese in the Gold Cup opener signals a potential shift in the pecking order. It provides Freese with a platform to demonstrate his capabilities on a competitive stage. It also sends a message to Turner that the starting position is not guaranteed.

The USMNT's goalkeeping history boasts names like Tony Meola, Kasey Keller, Brad Friedel, and Tim Howard. For a program with such a rich tradition of goalkeeping excellence, the current uncertainty might seem unusual. However, it also presents an opportunity for a new star to emerge. With the 2026 World Cup looming, the Gold Cup provides a crucial proving ground for both Turner and Freese. Only consistent playing time and outstanding performances will ultimately determine who will be the USMNT's number one when the world's eyes are on North America.