The first Test of the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy between India and England at Headingley, Leeds, marks a significant moment. It signifies the start of the 2025-2027 World Test Championship cycle and a new era for the Indian team following the retirements of Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma. Shubman Gill leads India for the first time in Tests, and the inclusion of fresh faces has generated considerable buzz. However, amidst the anticipation, one selection decision has sparked debate: the debut of Sai Sudharsan over Abhimanyu Easwaran. This has led many fans and cricket analysts to question, "What has Abhimanyu Easwaran done wrong?"

Abhimanyu Easwaran, a seasoned campaigner in the domestic circuit, boasts an impressive first-class record. As of October 2024, he had amassed 2,947 runs in 32 matches since 2021 at an average of 61.39, making him the highest-scoring Indian opener in First-Class cricket during that period. Overall, in 101 First-Class games, Easwaran has scored 7,674 runs at an average of 48.87, including 27 centuries. He has also captained the India A team and the Bengal Ranji team, showcasing his leadership qualities. In the recent India A series against England Lions, Easwaran scored twin fifties, further solidifying his credentials.

In contrast, Sai Sudharsan, while a promising talent, has a relatively modest first-class record. Before his debut, he had played 29 first-class matches, scoring 1957 runs at an average of 39.93 with 7 centuries. However, Sudharsan's recent form in the IPL 2025, where he won the Orange Cap, seems to have tilted the scales in his favor. He has also had county stints with Surrey, which might have helped his case.

Several factors contribute to the debate surrounding Easwaran's exclusion. Some argue that the selectors are prioritizing IPL performances over consistent domestic performances in red-ball cricket. Easwaran's father believes that the lack of IPL exposure has hindered his son's chances. Others suggest that the team management is looking at Sudharsan's potential and adaptability, especially considering his ability to bat at No. 3, a crucial position in the Test lineup.

Former cricketers and analysts have weighed in on the matter. Mohammed Kaif has publicly stated that Easwaran deserves to be in the playing XI before Sudharsan, citing Easwaran's 27 first-class hundreds and extensive experience. There's a sentiment that consistent performances in domestic cricket should be valued and rewarded, especially in Test cricket.

The decision to hand Sai Sudharsan his debut while overlooking Abhimanyu Easwaran has triggered a wave of discussions about the criteria for team selection. While Sudharsan's talent is undeniable, Easwaran's years of consistent performance in first-class cricket have made him a strong contender for a spot in the Test team. Only time will tell if Sudharsan can justify his selection, but the questions surrounding Easwaran's continued exclusion are unlikely to disappear anytime soon.