India's squad for the upcoming two-match Test series against South Africa has sparked a debate: who should bat at No. 3 in the first Test? The series begins on November 14 at Eden Gardens in Kolkata. While Sai Sudharsan has been the preferred choice for the past few series, Dhruv Jurel's recent form has made a strong case for his inclusion in the playing XI.
The Case for Dhruv Jurel
Dhruv Jurel has been in exceptional form in red-ball cricket, particularly during India A's unofficial Test series against South Africa A, where he struck centuries in both innings, scoring 132 and 127 not out. Overall, Jurel has scored four first-class hundreds in the last three months. His consistent performances have turned him into one of India's most promising batting talents. Jurel also averages around 48 in Test cricket and has displayed his grit and composure on a couple of occasions. In the last series against the West Indies, he scored his maiden Test century.
Former India captain Sourav Ganguly has also publicly backed Jurel's inclusion in the team. "But it depends on whom they want to send at No. 3 — whether they want to go with Sai Sudharsan, or bring in our in-form Dhruv in. We'll find out," Ganguly said.
The Case for Sai Sudharsan
Sai Sudharsan has been groomed for the No. 3 spot for the last couple of series. Although Sudharsan is still in the early stages of his red-ball career, the team management has faith in his ability to succeed in Test cricket. "We have faith in Sai's ability to crack the Test code. He's working hard and understands the demands of this position," Assistant coach Ryan ten Doeschate said.
Sudharsan's technique and temperament have earned the trust of captain Shubman Gill and head coach Gautam Gambhir. He has been a consistent performer in domestic tournaments like the Ranji Trophy, Vijay Hazare Trophy, and Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy. In the 2024 season of the IPL, Sudharsan finished as the top run-scorer for Gujarat Titans with 527 runs.
However, in seven Test innings, he has only managed 147 runs with a solitary half-century. He also failed to cross the fifty-run mark against South Africa A, scoring 84 runs from four innings.
The Dilemma for Selectors
The team management is cautious about making changes, especially with Sudharsan still in the mix. However, Jurel's rapid development may compel them to reconsider their options. The selectors face a dilemma, as dropping Sudharsan could be seen as unfair given his potential.
Ultimately, the decision of who should bat at No. 3 in the first Test against South Africa will depend on the team management's assessment of current form, potential, and the overall balance of the team. With both Jurel and Sudharsan presenting compelling cases, the choice is far from straightforward.
