Recent reports linking the Edmonton Oilers to Florida Panthers defenseman Aaron Ekblad have raised eyebrows across the NHL, but a closer examination suggests that this potential move is unlikely. While Ekblad is a talented player, several factors make him a less-than-ideal fit for the Oilers, particularly at the reported asking price.
According to NHL Network's David Pagnotta and EJ Hradek, the Oilers, along with the Toronto Maple Leafs and Detroit Red Wings, are among the teams interested in Ekblad if he becomes a free agent. Ekblad has expressed his desire to remain with the Panthers, but negotiations appear to be stalled due to a significant gap in contract expectations. Ekblad, who currently has a $7.5 million average annual value (AAV), is reportedly seeking a similar figure in his next deal, while the Panthers are said to be offering around $6 million or less.
While acquiring a player of Ekblad's caliber would seem like a boon for any team, the Oilers' specific circumstances make this move questionable. Edmonton has limited cap space this offseason, with several key players, including Evan Bouchard, requiring new contracts. Committing a significant portion of their available funds to Ekblad would restrict their ability to address other needs on the roster.
Furthermore, there are concerns about Ekblad's long-term value and fit within the Oilers' defensive structure. While he is a top-pairing defenseman, there is a growing perception that his effectiveness is somewhat inflated by his pairing with Gustav Forsling in Florida. The Oilers need players who elevate the performance of those around them, and there's doubt as to whether Ekblad fits that profile.
The Oilers have a solid defensive group already, including Evan Bouchard, Mattias Ekholm, Jake Walman and Darnell Nurse. Unless Nurse can be moved, which is highly unlikely, Ekblad will not be signing with the Oilers according to reports.
Ultimately, the Oilers may be better off exploring other options that provide better value and fit their long-term plans. Edmonton can't afford to gamble $6-7 million on a defenseman when other players on the roster need attention and potentially better fits are available at a lower price.
While the allure of adding a big-name player like Aaron Ekblad is understandable, a more pragmatic approach suggests that the Oilers should pass on this opportunity.