An ESPN analyst is facing criticism after suggesting the Indiana Fever are "more dangerous" without Caitlin Clark, sparking debate among fans and analysts alike. Carolyn Peck made the comments on ESPN, pointing out that Clark's ball-dominant style means defenses can focus their attention on neutralizing her. Without Clark, Peck argued, the Fever have more weapons and become a greater threat, specifically praising Kelsey Mitchell, Aari McDonald, and Aliyah Boston.

Peck's opinion has drawn the ire of many, particularly Clark's dedicated fanbase. Critics argue that statistics suggest the Fever are more effective with Clark on the court. Some have pointed to perceived negativity from ESPN analysts towards Clark since she entered the WNBA. This isn't the first time ESPN analysts have been called out regarding their coverage of Caitlin Clark. Previously, analysts selected Angel Reese as WNBA Rookie of the Year over Clark, which was met with criticism.

The timing of Peck's statement is notable, as it came after the Fever demonstrated strong performances during Clark's absence due to injury. In fact, the Fever blew out the Las Vegas Aces, winning by a score of 81-54. This marked the second consecutive contest where Indiana played great against one of the WNBA's most talented teams, as the Fever beat the Minnesota Lynx 74-59 to secure the WNBA Commissioner's Cup Championship. Some suggest that these wins validate Peck's argument, while others maintain that Clark's overall impact on the team and the WNBA is undeniable.

The "Caitlin Clark effect" has undeniably boosted the WNBA's popularity. Clark's college career at Iowa drew unprecedented viewership and attendance numbers. After being drafted by the Fever, she continued to break records, with her debut game becoming the most-watched WNBA game since 2002. The 2024 WNBA draft, where the Indiana Fever selected Clark with the first overall pick, averaged 2.45 million viewers, the most in WNBA draft history. The Fever also set a new single-season record with 340,715 fans in total home attendance for a WNBA team in 2024. Some estimate Clark's value to the league to be close to a billion dollars.

Despite the debate surrounding Peck's comments, the Indiana Fever's success is not solely dependent on one player. As one of Clark's teammates, Natasha Howard, stated that Clark doesn't have to do everything and that she should give some of her pressure to her teammates. Other players have stepped up, demonstrating the team's overall depth and potential. For example, Aari McDonald and Michaela Timson stepped up, making ESPN's pregame takes look foolish. The team has capable scorers that can help fill the void by committee. Kelsey Mitchell and Aliyah Boston will be leaned on heavily.

Ultimately, the controversy highlights the intense scrutiny and high expectations surrounding Clark and the Indiana Fever. While some analysts may question her immediate impact, her long-term influence on the WNBA and women's basketball is likely to be significant.