The Milwaukee Brewers find themselves in an enviable position as the 2025 MLB season progresses: a surplus of talent deserving of recognition. This "good problem to have" is highlighted by recent fan surveys regarding All-Star selections and potential trade targets, showcasing the depth and potential of the Brewers roster.
In a recent SB Nation Reacts survey, Brewers fans were asked to weigh in on which player was most deserving of representing the team at the All-Star game in Atlanta. While All-Star starters have already been announced, with no Brewers among them, the survey results reveal interesting insights into fan perceptions and player performance.
Brice Turang emerged as the clear frontrunner, garnering 40% of the vote. The 25-year-old shortstop has been exceptional, building upon a strong 2024 season where he hit .277/.341/.390 with six home runs, 38 RBIs, 45 runs, and 30 steals, earning him a Platinum Glove Award. This year, Turang has elevated his game even further, boasting a .288/.361/.380 slash line with five homers, 36 RBIs, 55 runs, and 17 steals through 83 games, along with his signature plus-plus defense. His 3.2 bWAR leads the team, making him a compelling All-Star candidate.
Freddy Peralta secured the second-highest percentage of votes at 26%. Peralta has had a dominant season, holding a 9-4 record with a 2.91 ERA and 3.84 FIP through 18 starts. He has also recorded 104 strikeouts in 99 innings, positioning him well to surpass 200 strikeouts for the third consecutive season.
Christian Yelich claimed 18% of the vote. Despite a slow start to the season, Yelich has been a consistent force since late May, hitting .259/.337/.466 with 17 home runs, 61 RBIs, 43 runs, and 12 steals in 81 games.
Beyond these top three, the Brewers have a number of other players who could be considered All-Star material, including Sal Frelick, William Contreras, Nick Mears, and Abner Uribe. This wealth of talent creates a "good problem" for the Brewers, as it demonstrates the team's overall strength and depth.
Another recent SB Nation Reacts survey focused on potential infield trade targets, revealing a split among fans regarding which player the Brewers should pursue. The candidates included Yoán Moncada, Ryan McMahon, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, and Miguel Vargas, with Moncada (36%) and McMahon (28%) leading the vote. This survey highlights the Brewers' potential need to bolster their infield and the diverse opinions among fans regarding the best course of action.
The Brewers' strong position extends beyond individual accolades and potential trades. The team is currently contending for a playoff spot, and their success can be attributed to a combination of factors, including strong pitching, timely hitting, and solid defense. As the trade deadline approaches, the Brewers have the opportunity to further strengthen their roster and solidify their chances of making a deep playoff run.
The Brewers also have an Alumni Home Run Derby scheduled for July 25 as part of the celebration for American Family Field's 25th anniversary. Fan surveys are also being conducted regarding who will win the Derby.
The "good problem" of having multiple deserving players and various options for improvement reflects the Brewers' overall health and competitiveness. As they navigate the remainder of the season, these decisions will be crucial in determining their ultimate success.
