Oilers fans hoping to see Carter Hart in Edmonton might be disappointed, as the acquitted goaltender remains ineligible to play in the NHL. This development puts a damper on speculation linking Hart to the Oilers, who are looking to solidify their goaltending situation.

Following Hart's acquittal in a sexual assault trial stemming from the 2018 World Junior team scandal, rumors began circulating about a potential NHL return, with the Oilers mentioned as a possible destination. Some analysts and fans believed that Hart could be a low-cost, high-upside option for Edmonton, especially given their need for a reliable goalie. However, despite the acquittal, Hart's eligibility to play remains uncertain.

Prior to his legal issues, Hart, drafted in the second round by the Philadelphia Flyers in 2016, had a promising NHL career. In 227 career games, he recorded a 96-93-29 record with a 2.94 goals-against average and a .906 save percentage. During the 2023-24 season, his last NHL appearance, Hart posted a 2.80 GAA and a .906 SV% in 26 games for the Flyers. Some observers noted that Hart's performance was sometimes undermined by the Flyers' defense, suggesting he could perform better with a stronger team in front of him.

The Oilers' need for a consistent goaltender has been a persistent issue. Their inconsistent goaltending was exposed during their recent Stanley Cup Final loss, prompting General Manager Stan Bowman to seek a solution. With limited options available in free agency and high trade costs, a "prove-it" deal with Hart was seen by some as a potentially shrewd move. It was speculated that Hart might accept a one-year contract in the $1 to $2 million range, representing a low-risk, high-reward opportunity for the Oilers.

Some argued that signing Hart would be a homecoming for the Alberta native, potentially motivating him to revive his career. Despite the potential for negative publicity, the Oilers providing a fresh start could be beneficial for both the player and the team.

However, insider Jason Gregor has downplayed the rumors, stating that the Oilers have not discussed signing Hart internally and are unlikely to pursue him. While the situation remains fluid, the latest update regarding Hart's ineligibility presents a significant obstacle to any potential deal with Edmonton.