The debate surrounding Auston Matthews' place among the NHL's elite centers has ignited once again, fueled by recent rankings that position him lower than many expected. Despite his undeniable goal-scoring prowess and status as the Toronto Maple Leafs' captain, some analysts and observers question whether he truly belongs in the top tier alongside Connor McDavid, Nathan MacKinnon, and Leon Draisaitl.
Each summer, the NHL Network releases its list of top 20 players at each position, which invariably sparks debate. In the most recent rankings, McDavid, MacKinnon, and Draisaitl held the top three spots, but Auston Matthews was placed at number seven. This ranking raised eyebrows, considering Matthews' track record as a three-time Rocket Richard Trophy winner and his past placement as high as number three on the same list. Aleksander Barkov, Sidney Crosby, and Jack Eichel were the three other centermen who ranked ahead of the Maple Leafs captain.
Several factors contribute to this perceived "disrespect." Matthews' 2024-25 season, while still productive, didn't reach the heights of his previous years. His 78 points (33 goals, 45 assists) in 67 games were considered a disappointment, especially after a 69-goal, 107-point season prior to that. Although he still outscored Eichel and Barkov, and had same number of goals as Crosby, his goal totals were nearly half of what they were in the prior year. Some analysts have also pointed to his two-way game, suggesting that while his offensive capabilities are undeniable, his defensive contributions may not be as consistent as those of other top centers.
However, others argue that Matthews' ranking is unduly harsh. They point to his league-leading goal total since entering the NHL in 2016-17, with 401 goals in 629 games, and his consistent ability to score at least 30 goals in each of his nine seasons, including two 60-goal seasons. His supporters also note that he was playing through an injury for a significant portion of the 2024-25 season, which likely impacted his performance. Furthermore, his strong two-way play was praised by new head coach Craig Berube. Despite injury, Matthews was confident he would be healthy for the start of the season.
The debate also highlights the different criteria used to evaluate players. Some prioritize offensive statistics, while others place greater emphasis on defensive play, leadership qualities, and playoff success. Connor McDavid is considered the best center because there is not a center in the NHL whom anyone would trade straight up for McDavid. Nathan MacKinnon is second best, and is only traded for McDavid.
Ultimately, Auston Matthews' place among the NHL's centers remains a matter of debate. While some may question his ranking based on a perceived down year and defensive inconsistencies, his goal-scoring record and overall impact on the game are undeniable. As he enters the 2025-26 season as the Maple Leafs' captain, he will have the opportunity to silence his doubters and solidify his position among the league's elite. If Matthews can remain healthy and pot 50-60 goals, he will rise up the center rankings for next year. However, Matthews will also need to perform in the playoffs for the Maple Leafs to pass some other centers on this list.
