The hockey world is buzzing as hypothetical Connor McDavid trade scenarios ignite social media, fueled by the Edmonton Oilers captain entering the final year of his contract. While McDavid has stated his "every intention to win in Edmonton," and is taking his time to consider all options, the lack of a signed extension has led to a flurry of speculation about his future.
Fans have taken to platforms like X (formerly Twitter) to propose blockbuster trades, ranging from realistic to outlandish. The hypothetical scenarios underscore McDavid's immense value and the potential frenzy that would ensue if he were ever available. As one fan bluntly stated, "Zero percent chance you get anything close to his actual value".
One rumored trade proposal involved the Los Angeles Kings offering a package including Quinton Byfield, Phillip Danault, Brandt Clarke, a goaltending prospect (either Carter George or Erik Portillo), and multiple first-round picks. Such a deal highlights the kind of franchise-altering return it would take for the Oilers to even consider parting with their superstar. Some believe that even that massive haul might not be enough.
The Oilers have felt the sting of back-to-back Stanley Cup Final losses to the Florida Panthers. McDavid has been consistent with his message that he wants to win in Edmonton. At the Hockey Canada Orientation Camp for the Olympic Winter Games Milano Cortina 2026, McDavid reiterated his commitment but also stated that "all options are on the table" and he doesn't have a preference as to when an extension is completed. This statement has intensified the speculation.
Most observers believe that McDavid will likely sign a three-to-four-year deal with Edmonton, possibly before the season starts. However, his recent comments suggest that the timeline is not set in stone, and he wants the flexibility that comes with waiting.
Some analysts suggest that McDavid might be waiting to see if the Oilers address their weaknesses before committing long-term. The team's roster, goaltending situation, and coaching staff remain largely the same, leaving McDavid in a similar position as last season. Others argue that McDavid's desire to win will lead him to take a team-friendly deal, allowing the Oilers to build a stronger team around him.
McDavid's former agent, Jeff Jackson, now the Oilers' CEO and president of hockey operations, will be involved in the negotiations, along with general manager Stan Bowman. Jackson has stated that the negotiations will be "unlike any other," suggesting a smooth and efficient process when McDavid is ready.
The potential market for McDavid is unprecedented, with comparisons being drawn to Shohei Ohtani, whose talent guarantees revenue and attention regardless of team affiliation. However, only a handful of teams could realistically accommodate McDavid's salary under the cap without significant roster changes.
Despite the uncertainty, many believe that McDavid will ultimately remain in Edmonton. His connection with teammate Leon Draisaitl, who recently signed an eight-year extension, is a significant factor. The Oilers have also made strategic additions to their roster, adding depth and youth.
Ultimately, the social media frenzy surrounding hypothetical McDavid trades highlights his unparalleled value and the high stakes involved in his contract negotiations. While the rumors may be just that for now, they serve as a reminder of what could be, and the pressure on the Oilers to secure their captain's future.
