Recent reports suggest that Max Pacioretty is likely to return to the Toronto Maple Leafs. After an injury-plagued but ultimately productive first season with the team, both Pacioretty and the Leafs have expressed interest in a new contract.

Pacioretty, who signed a one-year, $873,770 contract with Toronto on October 7, 2024, after a successful Professional Tryout, played 37 regular-season games, accumulating 13 points (5 goals, 8 assists). While his regular season was marked by injuries, his veteran presence and scoring touch proved valuable during the playoffs. In 13 postseason games, he contributed 8 points (3 goals, 5 assists), including a game-winning goal in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference First Round against the Ottawa Senators.

According to James Mirtle of The Athletic, there was mutual interest in getting a new contract signed. The news comes after Pacioretty hinted at retirement during his end-of-season media availability on May 20th, where he was noncommittal about his future and instead expressed a desire to spend time with his family.

Throughout the 2024-25 season, Pacioretty's experience and positive attitude were noted by teammates. After being sidelined with an injury since February 8th, his return to the lineup for Game 3 against the Senators was highly anticipated. Defenseman Chris Tanev highlighted Pacioretty's positive impact on the team, noting his ability to stay present and bring a fun, collaborative energy to the locker room.

Leafs GM Brad Treliving spoke about needing to change the overall DNA of the club after their latest playoff disappointment, but it doesn't look like bidding goodbye to Pacioretty will be part of those changes. Pacioretty's likely return alleviates one concern for Maple Leafs General Manager Brad Treliving as he focuses on reshaping the roster. Treliving has promised changes for the 2025-26 season after the team fell short in Game 7 to the Panthers.

Pacioretty's decision to potentially stay in Toronto offers stability and experience to a team looking to contend. While he may no longer be the top-line forward he once was, Pacioretty has proven his ability to contribute in a bottom-six role, especially during crucial playoff moments. At 36 years old, Pacioretty brings a wealth of experience, with 681 points (335 goals, 346 assists) in 939 career games. He ranks among the top American scorers in NHL history.

A potential contract extension would allow Pacioretty to continue his career on his terms, and Toronto could be the ideal environment for him to wind down his playing days. The Maple Leafs can offer him a comfortable option as his career winds down. While the team might bring him back on a league minimum contract for another year, a two-year deal for $2 million could be an option if they want to keep him around longer.