The Edmonton Oilers' search for a goaltending solution has become a major talking point this offseason, with fans expressing reservations about a potential gamble on a high-priced netminder. After back-to-back Stanley Cup Final losses, the spotlight is on the team's goaltending, and General Manager Stan Bowman has indicated that changes could be coming.
The Current Goaltending Situation
Currently, the Oilers have Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard under contract. Skinner has been the team's starter for the past two seasons, but his performance has been inconsistent. Pickard served as a solid backup last season, even exceeding expectations. However, there is a question of whether he is the right choice for a long-term tandem if that is what the Oilers desire.
Exploring the Trade Market
With the free agent market for goalies drying up, the Oilers have been exploring the trade market. NHL insider Jeff Marek has linked the Oilers to Tristan Jarry of the Pittsburgh Penguins. However, some question whether Jarry would be an upgrade over Pickard or Skinner.
The $15 Million Question
The idea of the Oilers acquiring a $15 million goalie has sparked debate among fans. Given the team's tight salary cap situation, committing that much money to a single player, especially a goalie with question marks, is a risky proposition. Some fans believe that the Oilers should focus on improving their defense and offensive depth rather than spending a large portion of their cap on a goalie.
Internal Options and Development
The Oilers have also been looking at internal options for their goaltending. Matt Tomkins was signed to a two-year deal and is expected to bring stability to the AHL's Bakersfield Condors. Samuel Jonsson, who had a strong season in Sweden, signed an entry-level contract and could also play for the Condors. Connor Ungar is heading into the second year of his entry-level contract and is likely to play in the ECHL again.
The Oilers have made changes to their coaching staff, hiring Peter Aubry as the new goaltending coach. Aubry has ties to GM Stan Bowman from their time in Chicago and has a strong background in goaltender development. Developing young goaltenders within the organization is seen as a key to long-term success. Arvid Soderblum, a restricted free agent with the Chicago Blackhawks, has worked with Peter Aubrey and could be a potential target for the Oilers.
The Fans' Perspective
Many fans are wary of the Oilers making a big splash for a high-priced goalie. They point to the team's previous struggles with goaltending contracts, such as the Jack Campbell signing, as a cautionary tale. There is a desire for the Oilers to find a more cost-effective and reliable solution in net. Some fans believe the team should stick with Skinner and Pickard, while others are open to exploring other options.
Ultimately, the Oilers' decision on their goaltending situation will have a significant impact on their success next season. While the allure of a big-name goalie is tempting, the team must weigh the risks and rewards before committing to a potentially expensive gamble.
