The recent removal of Axar Patel from the T20I vice-captaincy has stirred debate in the Indian cricketing fraternity, with former India cricketer Mohammad Kaif voicing strong opinions on the matter. The decision, made ahead of the Asia Cup 2025, has prompted questions and discussions about the rationale behind the change.

Axar Patel, an all-rounder who has proven his mettle with both bat and ball, was initially appointed as Suryakumar Yadav's deputy in the T20I side. This elevation came after India's T20 World Cup 2024 win and Hardik Pandya's exit. Patel's contributions to the team have been significant, showcasing his ability to choke opponents with his left-arm spin, anchor innings with the bat, and accelerate when needed. His utility across all departments made him a valuable asset to the team.

According to NDTV Sports Desk, Suryakumar Yadav addressed the situation at a press conference, revealing the reason for Shubman Gill's appointment as his deputy instead of Axar Patel. While the specific reason wasn't detailed, the decision appears to be a strategic one made by the team management and selectors.

Sunil Gavaskar has supported the decision to appoint Shubman Gill as vice-captain for the upcoming Asia Cup 2025.

Despite being a valuable asset, Axar has often been labeled as an "underdog". He was a key player in India's T20 World Cup-winning campaign last year, where he was utilized as a floater in the batting lineup by the then head coach Rahul Dravid and captain Rohit Sharma. Notably, his contributions include a 39-run partnership with Rishabh Pant against Pakistan and a 31-ball 47 against South Africa in the final. In the semi-final against England, he delivered a remarkable spell of 3/23.

Kaif's concern is that Axar's removal from the vice-captaincy warrants an explanation. While team dynamics and strategic decisions are part and parcel of the game, players who have consistently performed and contributed deserve clarity regarding changes in their roles.

Axar himself has maintained a positive attitude, stating that he doesn't feel the pressure of deserving a spot and focuses on performing whenever he gets an opportunity. He acknowledges that team combination and available room within the squad are crucial factors. When questioned about being named deputy to Suryakumar Yadav, Axar responded that it was the captain's and selectors' decision, and he remains focused on his role in the XI.

The decision to replace Axar Patel with Shubman Gill as the T20I vice-captain for the Asia Cup 2025 has sparked debate and highlights the complexities of team management and player selections. While the team's leadership has its reasons for the change, the situation underscores the importance of transparency and communication in maintaining team morale and ensuring that players understand the rationale behind decisions that affect their roles.