The Toronto Maple Leafs' goaltending situation is rapidly evolving from a minor concern to a full-blown crisis, making it increasingly difficult to ignore. After a promising 2024-25 season, where the tandem of Anthony Stolarz and Joseph Woll provided stability, the team finds itself grappling with inconsistent performances and uncertainty between the pipes.
The most recent setback occurred during Saturday's game against the Boston Bruins, where Stolarz was pulled after allowing four goals on 19 shots. This marked the first time Stolarz has been pulled for performance reasons during his tenure with the Maple Leafs. Stolarz, who signed a four-year, $15 million extension after last season, has struggled to replicate his previous form, with his save percentage dropping to below .890. His GAA this season sits at 3.35, with a .889 save percentage. "It's obviously not up to par," Stolarz admitted after the game. "It seems like every night I'm giving up one or two you want back.". He also took responsibility for his poor start against the Bruins, stating, "First & foremost I gotta bear down & make a save, giving up the first two shots not a good way to start the game".
Coach Craig Berube's patience seems to be wearing thin, as he stated postgame, "We all got to be better, including the goalie". The Leafs, who boasted the league's fourth-highest save percentage last season, are now languishing near the bottom in goals-against per game.
The team has been eagerly awaiting the return of Joseph Woll, who has been away on personal leave since September. Woll has started a conditioning stint with the AHL's Toronto Marlies. However, his first game back wasn't stellar either, as he allowed three goals on 24 shots in a losing effort. Woll himself acknowledged that he is still working on regaining his pace. "I think pace is something that I've found that is important to get up," Woll said. "I've had enough idle time and don't want to be practicing too long. I just want to get out and get going.".
With Stolarz struggling and Woll's return uncertain, the Maple Leafs recalled Dennis Hildeby, who made his season debut in relief against Boston, allowing one goal on 20 shots. Stolarz praised Hildeby's performance, saying, "He was awesome...I put him in a s— situation. He handled it like a true pro". It is unconfirmed if Hildeby will start against the Hurricanes.
The Maple Leafs also recently placed goaltender Cayden Primeau on waivers following Woll's return. Primeau, who was acquired to bolster goaltending depth during Woll's absence, had a 2-1-0 record with a 4.30 goals-against average and a .838 save percentage in three appearances.
Critics point out that the team's defensive performance has deteriorated, dropping them to 30th in goals allowed per game. The Leafs are allowing an average of 3.7 goals per game, ranking them 30th in the league. Some analysts suggest that Stolarz's struggles are compounded by the absence of Woll, who provided a solid tandem and consistent competition.
Looking ahead, the Maple Leafs face a challenging situation. If Stolarz can't regain his form and Woll isn't ready to assume the starting role, General Manager Brad Treliving may need to explore other options. The team's upcoming games will be crucial in determining the next course of action, and how they navigate this goaltending turbulence will significantly impact their aspirations for the season.
