The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) and the International Cricket Council (ICC) are currently embroiled in a dispute following accusations of "violations" stemming from a video involving match referee Andy Pycroft. The controversy arose during the Asia Cup 2025, adding another layer of drama to the already intense rivalry between India and Pakistan.

The core of the issue revolves around a handshake incident after a match between India and Pakistan. The PCB claimed that Pycroft barred the captains from shaking hands, a decision they strongly protested. They formally requested the ICC to remove Pycroft from officiating further Pakistan matches, alleging his actions were against the spirit of the game and a breach of the ICC Code of Conduct. This request was, however, denied by the ICC.

Adding fuel to the fire, the PCB released a statement asserting that Pycroft had apologized to the Pakistan team's captain and manager for the "no-handshake" incident, attributing it to "miscommunication". To support their claim, the PCB released a muted video of a conversation between Pycroft and members of the Pakistan team in the match referee's room.

However, the ICC has reportedly found the PCB guilty of multiple violations, including secretly recording the meeting with Andy Pycroft. The ICC is said to be unhappy with the PCB's video stunt and has sent a strongly worded letter to the PCB, pointing out the breach and warning of possible sanctions. According to sources, Pakistan's manager carried a mobile phone into the PMOA (Players and Match Officials Area) which is strictly prohibited and recorded a private discussion with Pycroft. The ICC's stance is that Pycroft only clarified his position and expressed regret over the "misunderstanding and miscommunication" rather than issuing an apology. Furthermore, the ICC has cleared Pycroft of any wrongdoing, stating that he was following instructions from the Asian Cricket Council (ACC) regarding the handshake protocol.

The PCB's actions have been met with criticism, with some reports suggesting that their version of events is false. A source told the Times of India that "There was no question of any apology. Especially from someone who did no wrong". The ICC maintains that the PCB's complaints are baseless.

This saga has created an awkward situation. The PCB finds itself in a difficult position, having publicized Pycroft's supposed apology while simultaneously expressing dissatisfaction that their request for his removal was rejected. This leaves the team caught in a controversy ahead of crucial Asia Cup matches.

The ICC's firm response underscores its commitment to upholding transparency and integrity in international cricket. The incident serves as a reminder of the importance of adhering to the established protocols and maintaining a high standard of conduct both on and off the field.