Recent reports have shed light on a potential controversy surrounding Pakistan's participation in the Asia Cup 2025, with claims that Mohsin Naqvi, the chairman of the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB), considered withdrawing the team from the tournament. This threat reportedly stemmed from a dispute over the appointment of ICC match referee Andy Pycroft, a decision that has created significant friction between the PCB and the International Cricket Council (ICC).

The PCB's dissatisfaction arose after a recent match where they felt Pycroft's actions were not in line with the spirit of cricket. Specifically, there were accusations that Pycroft advised the captains of India and Pakistan not to shake hands at the toss, which the PCB viewed as a breach of conduct. In response, the PCB demanded that the ICC remove Pycroft from his position for the remainder of the Asia Cup. However, the ICC refused to comply with this request, leading to heightened tensions.

The potential withdrawal from the Asia Cup could have significant financial implications for the PCB. Reports suggest that the board could lose between USD 12 to 16 million (INR 105-141 crore) if the team were to pull out. This amount constitutes a considerable portion of the PCB's projected annual revenue, potentially disrupting cricket development and operational plans. The revenue at stake comes from various sources, including broadcast rights, sponsorships, ticket sales, and digital viewership.

According to the Asian Cricket Council's (ACC) distribution structure, full member nations like Pakistan, India, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan each receive 15% of the body's earnings, which accounts for 75% of the total distribution. The remaining portion is allocated to associate member nations. By withdrawing, the PCB risked losing its guaranteed share, especially considering that broadcasters might withhold payments for matches not played, particularly the high-demand India vs. Pakistan encounters that drive significant revenue for the tournament.

Beyond the financial losses, a withdrawal could also negatively impact Pakistan's standing in the international cricket community. Such a decision could strain relationships with other full member nations who rely on balanced governance and revenue-sharing for the successful operation of the tournament.

Furthermore, the controversy has placed Mohsin Naqvi in a challenging position, given his dual role as PCB chairman and head of the ACC. A decision to withdraw could undermine his influence within the ACC and raise questions about his leadership.

Despite the threat of withdrawal, it appeared unlikely that Pakistan would take such drastic action, considering the significant financial losses and potential repercussions.