As the puck-drop for the 2025-26 NHL season rapidly approaches, the Toronto Maple Leafs face two critical decisions that could significantly impact their early performance and overall trajectory. Coach Craig Berube and General Manager Brad Treliving must finalize the opening night roster, with particular attention to two key areas: the composition of the top line and the readiness of prospect Easton Cowan for the NHL.
The first decision revolves around who will fill the void left by Mitch Marner on the top line, alongside Auston Matthews. Marner's absence necessitates a reshuffling of the forward lines, and Berube has been experimenting with different combinations throughout the preseason. One option gaining traction is Max Domi, who has received the backing of Auston Matthews himself. Domi brings a combination of skill and grit, and his offensive instincts could complement Matthews' goal-scoring prowess. However, other candidates may still be in the mix, and the coaching staff will need to assess which player provides the best chemistry and overall balance to the top line. The ultimate choice will need to maximize Matthews' offensive impact while also providing defensive responsibility.
The second major decision concerns the readiness of Easton Cowan. Cowan has impressed throughout training camp and the preseason, showcasing a level of maturity and adaptability that has caught the attention of the coaching staff. His strong play has led some to believe he has earned a spot on the opening night roster. Berube has acknowledged Cowan's progress and NHL readiness but has stopped short of guaranteeing him a place on the team. The Leafs must weigh the benefits of having Cowan gain valuable NHL experience early in the season against the potential drawbacks of rushing his development. Sending him back to the OHL for further seasoning is another option. If the Leafs believe Cowan is ready to contribute at the NHL level, keeping him on the roster could provide a spark and inject youth and enthusiasm into the lineup. However, if they feel he needs more time to develop his game, sending him back to junior could be the wiser long-term decision.
These decisions aren't just about filling spots; they are about setting the tone for the season. A strong start can build confidence and momentum, while early struggles can create doubts and pressure. Berube's ability to identify the right mix of players and Cowan's development will be crucial factors in determining the Maple Leafs' success in the opening weeks of the season.
