The Calgary Flames' decision not to claim a goaltender off waivers has raised eyebrows and sparked debate among hockey insiders, given the team's uncertain situation behind starting netminder Dustin Wolf. With the 2025-26 NHL season now underway, the Flames' goaltending depth is under scrutiny, and the choice to stand pat is being questioned.
Following the departure of Dan Vladar in free agency, the Flames aimed to solidify their backup position by signing Ivan Prosvetov from Russia. However, Prosvetov's shaky preseason performance led to him being placed on waivers and subsequently assigned to the AHL. Devin Cooley, the other contender for the backup role, also struggled to impress, leaving the Flames with limited reliable options behind Wolf.
"I'll tell you one team people are wondering about is Calgary," NHL insider Elliotte Friedman said recently. "We all know who their number one is, but neither Cooley or Prosvetov had great preseasons. I kind of wonder if Calgary might take a shot at somebody here. It's just is the timing right with what they have?".
Several experienced goaltenders were recently available on the waiver wire, including Michael DiPietro, Nico Daws and Alexandar Georgiev. DiPietro, despite clearing waivers, has a two-year deal and a strong AHL track record. Daws has NHL experience with the Devils, and Georgiev was recently placed on waivers by the Buffalo Sabres after they claimed Colten Ellis. Any of these goalies could potentially provide an upgrade over Cooley or Prosvetov.
The decision not to pursue a waiver claim suggests that the Flames' management has confidence in either Cooley's ability to rebound or Prosvetov's potential for improvement in the AHL. Flames head coach Ryan Huska indicated familiarity with Cooley, and stated there were parts of Prosvetov's game that needed work. He also noted the fluidity of the situation, emphasizing the need to find players who can help the team win.
However, relying on unproven backups carries significant risk. Dustin Wolf is considered the future of the Flames' goaltending and is expected to carry a significant load this season. But as one analysis pointed out, Wolf can't carry the load forever. Should Wolf falter or suffer an injury, the Flames' playoff aspirations could be jeopardized if the backup situation isn't resolved.
Some observers believe the Flames may be prioritizing internal development and giving Cooley and Prosvetov an opportunity to prove themselves at the NHL level. Others suggest the team's management may be hesitant to add salary or commit to another goaltender when they have existing investments in Wolf, Cooley, and Prosvetov.
Ultimately, the Flames' gamble on their current goaltending depth will be put to the test as the season progresses. Whether their faith in Cooley or Prosvetov will be rewarded, or whether the decision not to grab a goalie off waivers will haunt them, remains to be seen.
