The Edmonton Oilers find themselves at a crossroads early in the 2025-26 NHL season. A disappointing 4-4-1 start has ignited a passionate debate among the fanbase, with fingers pointing in various directions as to the cause of the team's underwhelming performance. While the usual suspects like inconsistent goaltending and defensive lapses have been mentioned, a surprising new focal point has emerged: the absence of assistant coach Paul Coffey from behind the bench.
Coffey, a Hall of Fame defenseman, transitioned from a bench role to a special advisor to ownership and hockey operations in July. This move was part of a broader coaching staff shuffle that saw Paul McFarland join as an assistant coach, Peter Aubry replace Dustin Schwartz as goaltending coach, and Connor Allen brought in as a skills coach. While the changes were intended to inject new life into the team, some fans believe Coffey's absence has created a void, particularly in the team's organization and defensive structure.
This theory has gained traction on social media, with fans suggesting the Oilers' struggles on the blue line are a direct result of Coffey no longer being present to guide the defensemen. However, this viewpoint is not universally shared. Some analysts and fans argue that attributing the team's woes solely to Coffey's departure is an oversimplification.
Bruce Curlock, an NHL prospect aficionado, pointed out that the team's record through the first nine games last season wasn't significantly better, suggesting deeper issues are at play. He cautioned against assuming Coffey was a difference-maker. Some observers point to the numerous offseason changes, including the departures of veteran players such as Evander Kane, Connor Brown, and Corey Perry, coupled with the coaching adjustments, as the primary source of the team's early-season struggles. The integration of new players and coaching philosophies often takes time, and the Oilers may simply be experiencing growing pains.
Goaltending has also come under scrutiny, with some fans highlighting inconsistent play between the pipes as a persistent problem. While neither Stuart Skinner nor Calvin Pickard rank among the league's worst in goals saved above expected, both are striving for improved performance.
Head coach Kris Knoblauch's lineup management has also drawn criticism. Some fans have expressed frustration with the constant line changes, arguing that it prevents players from developing chemistry and comfort. The projected lineup for the October 26th game against the Vancouver Canucks sees Andrew Mangiapane on the first line with Connor McDavid and Jack Roslovic.
Adding to the Oilers' challenges is the performance of key players like Evan Bouchard, whose defensive miscues have been costly. Despite his offensive contributions, Bouchard's turnovers and poor pinches have led to goals against, raising questions about whether Knoblauch should reduce his ice time to send a message.
Ultimately, the Oilers' slow start appears to be a multifaceted issue with no single, easy solution. While some fans fixate on the coaching changes, particularly Coffey's move away from the bench, others point to roster turnover, goaltending inconsistencies, and lineup decisions as contributing factors. As the season progresses, it will be up to Knoblauch and the coaching staff to address these concerns and find a way to unlock the team's full potential. The fans, divided as they may be, will be watching closely, hoping to see the Oilers return to their contender status.
