The role of a backup goaltender in the NHL is crucial, providing stability and a reliable presence behind the starter. These netminders are called upon to step in due to injuries, fatigue, or simply to give the primary goalie a night off. Identifying the top performers in this role requires a look at their consistency, save percentage, goals-against average, and overall impact on their team. Here’s a look at ten of the best NHL backup goaltenders in 2025.

1. Eric Comrie (Winnipeg Jets)

Comrie provides a solid and dependable option behind Connor Hellebuyck in Winnipeg. With Hellebuyck having won three Vezina Trophies, including the past two, and even the Hart Trophy as league MVP last season, having a reliable backup like Comrie is invaluable for managing the workload throughout the long season.

2. Jake Allen (New Jersey Devils)

Allen was one of the most sought-after goaltenders in the UFA market. Last season, in 31 appearances for New Jersey, Allen proved to be a dependable second option.

3. Joseph Woll (Toronto Maple Leafs)

Woll has shown flashes of brilliance and has the potential to steal starts. His performance metrics are impressive, making him a strong contender to challenge for more playing time.

4. Charlie Lindgren (Washington Capitals)

Lindgren provides a steady and experienced presence in Washington. His consistency allows the Capitals to confidently manage the workload of their starting goalie, Logan Thompson.

5. Casey DeSmith (Dallas Stars)

DeSmith had some nice backup numbers with Pittsburgh earlier in his career before having a subpar 2022-23 and 2023-24, but he was a top-tier backup last year in Dallas with a .915 save percentage.

6. Jonathan Quick (NY Rangers)

Quick, a veteran with a wealth of experience, brings leadership and Stanley Cup-winning pedigree to the Rangers. Serving as a backup to Igor Shesterkin, Quick’s experience is invaluable.

7. Scott Wedgewood (Colorado Avalanche)

Wedgewood is a reliable option for the Avalanche, providing stability and a capable presence when called upon.

8. Leevi Merilainen (Ottawa Senators)

Merilainen was one of the best goalies in the NHL across his 12-game sample size last year. The Senators were impressed enough to let Anton Forsberg leave in free agency and anoint Merilainen their long-term No. 2.

9. Anton Forsberg (Los Angeles Kings)

Forsberg had 2.2 goals saved above expected last season, which suggests he cancelled out some stinkers with some standout games.

10. Jakub Dobes (Montreal Canadiens)

Dobes had some impressive flashes in his limited duty. Both netminders have the upside to build on last season's performances if the team around them matures.

These backup goalies provide their teams with the reassurance that they can maintain a competitive level even when the starter needs rest or is sidelined. Their performances are vital for team success, especially during the grueling NHL season and the high-stakes playoffs.