The Edmonton Oilers' quest for a reliable goaltender continues to be a dominant storyline this season, but finding the right fit in what many are calling a "non-existent market" presents a significant challenge. With the possibility of acquiring Juuse Saros seemingly off the table, the Oilers must explore alternative options that won't cripple their salary cap or deplete their asset pool.

The Oilers' current goaltending tandem of Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard has been inconsistent. While Skinner has shown flashes of brilliance, his save percentage of .900 over the past three seasons is just below league average. Some argue that "league average goaltending isn't bringing a Stanley Cup to Edmonton". Pickard, while a competent depth option, isn't considered a reliable tandem partner for a contender.

General Manager Stan Bowman acknowledges the team's goaltending hasn't been elite, but he also believes defensive breakdowns and inconsistent forward play contribute to the problem. While Bowman is monitoring the goalie market, he doesn't think any available trades are "worth it" at the current asking prices. The lack of available talent and the Oilers' desperation are driving up the cost of potential acquisitions.

So, if not Saros, then who? Here are some potential, albeit imperfect, targets for the Oilers:

• Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen: The Buffalo Sabres goalie could benefit from a change of scenery. At 26, UPL has the size and athleticism teams look for, but his inconsistency and confidence issues are a concern. With a $4.75M cap hit, he's a gamble.
• Cam Talbot: A familiar face in Edmonton, Talbot could be a short-term, low-drama solution. At 38, he's no longer a starter, but he provides predictability without requiring a long-term commitment or significant assets.
• Arvid Soderblom: With Spencer Knight emerging as the starter in Chicago, Soderblom could be available. At $2.75M through 2027, he's an affordable option with upside as a tandem partner. Bowman has familiarity with Soderblom, but he's still unproven.
• David Rittich or Semyon Varlamov: Once Varlamov returns from injury, the Islanders may have a surplus in net. Rittich might be the more sensible option, though neither is necessarily a significant upgrade over Skinner.

The reality of the NHL goalie market in 2025 is that Edmonton doesn't need a superstar. They need someone better than what they have, at a price they can afford. As TSN's Pierre LeBrun asked, "Who's available that's a tangible upgrade?".

Given the limited options and Bowman's reluctance to overpay, the Oilers may ultimately stick with Skinner and Pickard, hoping for improved consistency and team defense. However, with Connor McDavid in his prime, the pressure to find a solution in net remains intense. The coming weeks and months will reveal whether Bowman can find a suitable goalie to help the Oilers make a serious push for the Stanley Cup.