The NHL's intense goaltending market has taken an unexpected turn this offseason, with multiple teams exploring unconventional options to solidify their netminding. According to player agent Allan Walsh, five teams contacted retired goalie Marc-André Fleury to gauge his interest in returning to the league. While the specific teams remain undisclosed, the situation highlights the desperation some franchises face in securing reliable goaltending.

Could the Edmonton Oilers be among those teams? The Oilers' goaltending has been a persistent topic of discussion and a point of concern despite their recent Stanley Cup Final appearances. The tandem of Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard has been criticized for inconsistency, leading many to believe that changes are necessary to push the team over the top.

Skinner, despite his potential and experience gained from two deep playoff runs, has struggled with consistency. While capable of strong performances, he has also exhibited stretches of subpar play. Pickard, initially signed as a third-string goalie, stepped up admirably during the 2025 playoffs, even boasting a 7-0 start. However, questions remain about whether he is the ideal long-term solution as a reliable backup.

The Oilers' apparent need for goaltending stability has led to speculation about potential acquisitions. Names like Ilya Sorokin, Juuse Saros, Jeremy Swayman, Jordan Binnington, and Thatcher Demko have been mentioned as possible targets, though acquiring any of these established starters would likely require significant assets and cap maneuvering. The possibility of pursuing Demko from the Vancouver Canucks has also been discussed, although his injury history presents a considerable risk.

Given this context, it's plausible that the Oilers explored the possibility of luring Fleury out of retirement. Fleury, a veteran with a decorated career, could have provided a short-term solution and a wealth of experience. However, several factors might have dissuaded the Oilers from seriously pursuing this option. Fleury's age and recent retirement suggest he may not be the ideal fit for a team aiming for sustained success. Furthermore, the Oilers might prefer to invest in a younger, more long-term option to solidify their goaltending situation.

Instead of pursuing a retired goalie, the Oilers may focus on other avenues to improve their goaltending. One option is to retain Skinner while finding a more reliable and experienced backup than Pickard. Another approach could involve trading for a proven starter, although the cost of acquiring such a player could be substantial. The Oilers have already made changes to their goaltending coaching staff, signaling a commitment to improving Skinner's consistency and overall performance.

Ultimately, whether the Oilers were among the teams that contacted Fleury remains uncertain. However, the fact that multiple teams explored this unconventional option underscores the intense pressure to find reliable goaltending in a league where a strong netminder can be the difference between success and failure. As the offseason progresses, the Oilers will need to carefully evaluate their options and make strategic decisions to address their goaltending concerns and maximize their chances of contending for the Stanley Cup.