The Toronto Maple Leafs recently traded Ryan Reaves to the San Jose Sharks in exchange for defenseman Henry Thrun. Thrun, a 24-year-old left-shot defenseman, has one year remaining on his contract with a $1 million average annual value. Reaves, 38, has one year remaining on his contract with a $1.35 million AAV.
Toronto Maple Leafs: B+
The Maple Leafs get a reasonable grade for this trade, as they managed to turn an underperforming asset in Reaves into a younger player with potential in Thrun. Reaves, while well-liked by teammates and providing some toughness, did not make a significant impact on the ice and was even waived at one point. He had just two assists in 35 games last season and did not appear in the playoffs. Swapping Reaves for Thrun, who can compete for a spot on the Leafs' blue line, is a savvy move. While Thrun's defensive metrics last season were not impressive, playing on a rebuilding Sharks team likely contributed to those numbers. Thrun posted two goals and 12 points in 60 games for the Sharks last season. He should benefit from playing in a stronger Leafs lineup.
San Jose Sharks: C+
The Sharks' grade is a bit lower, but the trade still makes sense for them. San Jose is in a rebuilding phase and can absorb Reaves' cap hit without hindering their long-term goals. Reaves can bring needed physicality and protection for their young players. General Manager Mike Grier expressed excitement about adding Reaves' energy, personality, and toughness to the team, noting his history of being on winning teams. The Sharks also have a surplus of left-handed defensemen and needed to create roster space, particularly if prospect Sam Dickinson is ready for the NHL.
Overall, the trade appears to be a win-win for both teams, addressing their specific needs. The Maple Leafs get younger and add potential to their defense, while the Sharks acquire a veteran presence to help guide their rebuild.
