Shubman Gill's captaincy and on-field demeanor during the ongoing Test series against England have sparked debate, with some observers suggesting he is trying to emulate Virat Kohli's aggressive style. Former India cricketer Manoj Tiwary has openly criticized Gill, stating that he is "copying" Kohli and that this approach is not benefiting his batting.

Tiwary's comments come in the wake of India's narrow 22-run defeat in the third Test at Lord's, where Gill's animated exchanges with England players, particularly Zak Crawley, drew attention. Gill's behavior was perceived by some as an attempt to inject energy and assertiveness into the team, similar to Kohli's trademark approach. However, Tiwary believes that Gill's actions are forced and unnatural.

"Ever since he became a captain in the IPL, I have noticed he is getting into an aggressive mindset and having animated chats with umpires. It was unlike Gill," Tiwary told SportsBoom.com. He added, "He doesn't need to show that kind of aggression and doesn't have to prove anything". Tiwary further noted that such displays of aggression can be counterproductive, draining energy that could be better utilized in batting.

Gill himself has acknowledged the influence of both Kohli and Rohit Sharma, stating that he admires Kohli's hunger and passion and Sharma's attacking mindset. However, he also emphasized the importance of forging his own path as captain. Despite these assertions, some instances during the England series have fueled comparisons between Gill and Kohli. For example, Gill's celebration at Edgbaston bore a striking resemblance to Kohli's century celebration at the same venue in 2018.

Former England all-rounder Moeen Ali has also weighed in on the debate, observing similarities between Gill's aggression and Kohli's approach. While Ali doesn't necessarily view Gill's behavior as problematic, he suggests that it may have inadvertently motivated England, bringing out "the best of England and the fight and that beast England can be".

The pressure on Gill is immense, especially following the series of events at Lord's. Gill's efforts to emulate the aggressive nature of Virat Kohli and the calmness of Rohit Sharma may hinder his individuality. To lead effectively, he must embrace his unique style and not mimic any of the past legends. Some fans and cricket experts criticized Shubman Gill's behavior after India lost the match to England.

Ultimately, whether Gill's attempts to emulate Kohli are conscious or subconscious, the key lies in finding a balance that aligns with his own personality and leadership style. As Virender Sehwag's experience demonstrates, true success comes from embracing one's own identity rather than trying to replicate someone else. Gill must create his own climate in England.