The New York Islanders have dramatically reshaped their prospect pool in a single year, transitioning from one of the league's weakest to a system brimming with potential. Several factors contributed to this transformation, including a successful 2024 NHL Entry Draft, strategic trades, and the emergence of key prospects.
The 2024 NHL Entry Draft: A Turning Point
For years, the Islanders were known for trading away draft picks in favor of acquiring established players, leaving their prospect pool depleted. However, the 2024 draft marked a change in approach. With their first pick since 2019, the Islanders selected left wing Cole Eiserman at No. 20 overall. Eiserman, known for his exceptional goal-scoring ability, was widely considered a steal at that spot. The team also drafted defenseman Jesse Pulkkinen, and center Kamil Bednarik in the second round, adding further depth to their prospect pool. Goaltenders Dmitry Gamzin and Marcus Gidlof, and defenseman Xavier Veilleux were also selected.
Key Acquisitions and Trades
Beyond the draft, strategic trades have also played a role in the Islanders' prospect pool transformation. The acquisition of Calum Ritchie from the Colorado Avalanche has bolstered their center depth.
Top Prospects Emerge
Several young players have emerged as potential future stars for the Islanders. Matthew Schaefer, the first overall pick in the 2025 NHL Draft, is considered by some to be the league's top prospect. Daily Faceoff's Steven Ellis lauded Schaefer as "close to a perfect puck-moving defender" with potential for Norris Trophy contention. Other highly-ranked prospects include:
Rankings Reflect the Change
The influx of talent has significantly improved the Islanders' prospect pool ranking. For years, the Islanders were routinely ranked near the bottom. In 2024, EP Rinkside ranked the Islanders' prospect pool at No. 24. McKeen's Hockey had the Islanders' prospect system ranked 26th. The Athletic and Daily Faceoff have ranked the Islanders much higher in their recent prospect rankings. Five Islanders prospects were ranked in the top 27 by Daily Faceoff.
Looking Ahead
While the Islanders' NHL roster has several players who may bounce back and have a better season in 2025-26, the team's long-term success hinges on the development of its top prospects. Matthew Schaefer appears to have a good chance of being in the lineup when the season opens against the Pittsburgh Penguins on October 9. The Islanders' development camp roster included forwards Kamil Bednarik, Cole Eiserman and Victor Eklund. With a combination of high-end talent and increased depth, the Islanders' prospect pool is now a source of optimism for the future.
