Easton Cowan's trajectory since being drafted 28th overall in the 2023 NHL Draft has Maple Leafs management facing a crucial decision: should they ease him into the NHL or thrust him into a prominent role right away?
Cowan's performance in the Ontario Hockey League (OHL) has been nothing short of spectacular. Last season, he tallied 69 points in 46 games. His dominance continued into the playoffs, where he led all scorers with 39 points in 17 games, guiding the London Knights to a Memorial Cup championship. He also earned the Stafford Smythe Memorial Trophy as the tournament's most valuable player. In the 2023-24 season, Cowan posted 96 points (34 goals, 62 assists) and was awarded the Red Tilson Trophy as OHL MVP and the Gretzky 99 Award as playoff MVP.
At 20 years old, Cowan is entering Maple Leafs training camp with a legitimate shot at securing a roster spot. His skill, speed, and ability to perform under pressure have made him the centerpiece of Toronto's prospect pool. Assistant General Manager Hayley Wickenheiser has expressed confidence in Cowan's readiness, stating that he will be given every opportunity to earn a spot with the Maple Leafs. She believes he will be fit and prepared enough to step in and play. Coach Dale Hunter has also lauded Cowan, stating that he will push to make the Leafs better right away.
However, there are valid arguments for a more cautious approach. At 5-foot-11 and 185 pounds, Cowan's size is slightly below the NHL average. The grind of an NHL season could expose players still developing physically. Some believe that time with the Toronto Marlies of the American Hockey League (AHL) would allow him to develop without the intense pressure of the NHL. Playing top-line minutes and contributing on special teams in the AHL could further refine his skills and adapt his game to the professional level.
General Manager Brad Treliving has emphasized the importance of long-term development. He acknowledges the excitement surrounding Cowan but stresses the need to avoid rushing him, which could negatively impact his progress. Treliving stated the organization sees Cowan as a major part of their future and will make the decision that is ultimately best for him.
The decision of whether to push Cowan or tread carefully is a complex one with potential benefits and risks. Pushing him into the NHL could provide an immediate spark to the team, especially with the departure of key players like Mitch Marner. Cowan's tenacity, hockey IQ, and playmaking abilities could make him a valuable asset. However, a cautious approach, allowing him to develop in the AHL, could ensure his long-term success and prevent him from being overwhelmed early in his career. Ultimately, the Maple Leafs must weigh Cowan's readiness against the potential risks of rushing his development.
