As the 2025-26 NHL season finds the Toronto Maple Leafs looking to solidify their roster, potential trades are a hot topic, and two Buffalo Sabres forwards have emerged as possible targets: Tage Thompson and Alex Tuch. While Thompson's offensive prowess is undeniable, a closer look suggests that Tuch would be a more sensible acquisition for the Leafs.
Thompson, 27, is a towering presence with a knack for scoring, evidenced by his two 40-goal seasons. His $7.14 million cap hit is manageable, especially with the rising salary cap. However, acquiring Thompson would require the Leafs to part with significant assets, including roster players, prospects, and draft picks. Moreover, Thompson possesses a modified no-trade clause, granting him some control over his destination.
Tuch, on the other hand, presents a more appealing package for Toronto. At 29, he is in the prime of his career and offers a blend of skill, grit, and two-way reliability. Tuch is also in the final year of his contract, with a more affordable $4.75 million cap hit. This makes him a more financially viable option for the Leafs, who are already navigating a tight payroll.
Several factors point to Tuch being a better fit for the Maple Leafs. First, his contract situation makes him a potentially cheaper acquisition than Thompson. With Tuch eligible for unrestricted free agency after this season, the Sabres might be more willing to move him for a reasonable return rather than risk losing him for nothing.
Second, Tuch's playing style aligns well with what the Leafs need. He is a strong two-way winger who can contribute offensively while also playing a responsible defensive game. This versatility would allow him to slot into various roles within the Leafs' top-six forward group. Tuch consistently delivers 60-plus point seasons and contributes defensively.
Third, Tuch's character and leadership qualities would be a valuable addition to the Leafs' dressing room. He is known as a leader on the Sabres, both on and off the ice. Adding a player with his experience and demeanor could help solidify the Leafs' team culture. Tuch has expressed a desire to re-sign with the Sabres, but negotiations have been put on pause.
While Thompson's offensive firepower is tempting, the cost of acquiring him and his potential fit within the team make Tuch a more logical target for the Maple Leafs. Tuch's contract situation, playing style, and leadership qualities make him a better fit for the Leafs' needs and budget. As the season progresses, it will be interesting to see if the Leafs pursue a trade for Tuch and whether the Sabres are willing to part with their valuable winger. The Sabres and Tuch were not close to agreeing on a new contract, and if the Sabres do not improve by late November, Tuch is as good as gone.
