The pressure is mounting on Shubman Gill as India seeks to level the series against South Africa in the second Test in Guwahati, starting on November 22. Gill, the designated captain for the Test series, sustained a neck injury during the first Test in Kolkata, casting a shadow over his participation in the crucial upcoming match. While the BCCI has confirmed that Gill will travel with the team to Guwahati, his availability remains uncertain, pending further assessment by the medical team.
Adding to the complexity of the situation is the resurgence of Shreyas Iyer. Once sidelined and without a central contract, Iyer has forced his way back into contention with a string of impressive performances, most notably in the IPL. His leadership skills and match-winning abilities have sparked discussions about his potential inclusion in the Test squad and even a challenge for the captaincy in the future.
This presents Shubman Gill with a difficult choice. Should he risk further aggravating his neck injury in a desperate attempt to lead India to victory and save the Test series? Or should he prioritize his long-term fitness and allow Iyer the opportunity to prove his mettle in the Test arena?
The circumstances surrounding Gill's injury are concerning. He sustained a neck spasm while batting in the first innings of the Kolkata Test and was subsequently hospitalized. He was later ruled out of the remainder of the match. While the BCCI has stated that Gill is responding well to treatment, the risk of re-injury remains a significant factor.
The potential consequences of Gill playing while not fully fit could be severe, not only for the team but also for his own career. A premature return could lead to a prolonged absence, jeopardizing his chances in future series and potentially hindering his development as a leader.
On the other hand, sitting out the second Test would be a major blow to India's chances of winning the series. Following their defeat in Kolkata, the team desperately needs a victory to restore confidence and level the score. Gill's presence at the top of the order would undoubtedly strengthen the batting lineup and provide stability.
However, the emergence of Shreyas Iyer as a potential replacement adds a new dimension to the equation. Iyer's recent form and leadership qualities cannot be ignored. An unnamed official told the Indian Express that after this IPL they can't keep him out of T20 internationals and even Tests. Giving Iyer an opportunity in the second Test could prove to be a shrewd move, injecting fresh energy and experience into the team.
Ultimately, the decision rests with Shubman Gill and the team management. They must carefully weigh the risks and benefits of Gill's participation, considering both the immediate need for victory and the long-term implications for his career. The "Shreyas Iyer factor" adds pressure, potentially influencing Gill to prioritize his health.
As of November 19, 2025, Gill is traveling to Guwahati with the team and will be monitored by the BCCI medical team. A final decision regarding his participation in the second Test will be made in due course. In Gill's absence, Rishabh Pant, who was Gill's deputy, will lead India in the second Test of the Freedom Trophy 2025.
