The hockey world is abuzz with a new debate: Are Macklin Celebrini and Connor Bedard on track to surpass the NHL's established elite, Connor McDavid and Nathan MacKinnon? While McDavid and MacKinnon have dominated the scoring charts for years, the emergence of Celebrini and Bedard is shaking up the conversation.

The Established Elite

Nathan MacKinnon, at 30 years old, is currently setting the pace with a remarkable 49 points in 29 games. His shooting efficiency and ice time demonstrate a player at the peak of his abilities. McDavid, though having a "quiet" season by his own standards, still boasts an impressive 42 points in 29 games. Even in a "slow" year, his playmaking ability remains a force. In a game earlier in the year, MacKinnon scored twice, but a goal and late assist from McDavid contributed to the Oiler's 4-3 comeback victory over the Avalanche.

The Phenoms Rise

Macklin Celebrini, the 19-year-old rookie, has quickly become a player to watch. As of December 9th, he tallied 43 points in 30 games. Before being drafted into the NHL, Celebrini played in the NCAA for Boston University, where he scored 32 goals and 32 assists in 38 games. Connor Bedard, 20, is also making waves and is currently top five in points.

The early success of Celebrini and Bedard has drawn comparisons to legends like Wayne Gretzky and Steve Yzerman. On November 19, 2025, Bedard and Celebrini made history after becoming the second pair of players aged 20 or under to record hat tricks on the same night. Celebrini netted all three of the San Jose Sharks' goals in their 3-2 win, and Bedard tallied three goals in the Chicago Blackhawks' victory.

By the Numbers

As of December 9, 2025, the stats speak volumes:

• Nathan MacKinnon: 49 points in 29 games, 133 shots
• Connor McDavid: 42 points in 29 games, 87 shots
• Macklin Celebrini: 43 points in 30 games

The Road Ahead

While Celebrini and Bedard have demonstrated exceptional skill, the grueling NHL season can test even the brightest stars. Both players face the challenge of maintaining consistency and avoiding slumps. The context of their teams also plays a significant role, as both Chicago and San Jose are in rebuilding phases. This means their supporting casts are still developing, which could impact their point production.

Looking ahead, both Celebrini and Bedard will be vying for roster spots on Team Canada for the 2026 Olympics. This adds another layer of competition and pressure as they continue to develop their games.

The Verdict

It's still early in their careers, but Macklin Celebrini and Connor Bedard are undoubtedly rising stars who are injecting excitement into the NHL. Whether they will ultimately surpass McDavid and MacKinnon remains to be seen, but their talent and potential suggest a bright future for the league. The comparison is unavoidable, and it will be exciting to watch these young players continue to push the boundaries of the game.