Oilers Appear to Be Emerging as Clear Winners in Savoie-McLeod Trade with Sabres

In a move that initially raised eyebrows around the league, the Edmonton Oilers traded forward Ryan McLeod and prospect Ty Tullio to the Buffalo Sabres in exchange for Matt Savoie. While both teams aimed to address specific needs with the deal, the early returns suggest that the Oilers are increasingly looking like the victors in this transaction.

At the time of the July 2024 trade, Ryan McLeod was coming off a career year with the Oilers, having posted 12 goals and 18 assists in 81 games. He also played a crucial role in Edmonton's run to the Stanley Cup Final, contributing four goals in 24 playoff games. McLeod's versatility as a bottom-six center and his effectiveness on the penalty kill made him a valuable asset. Tullio, a fifth-round pick from 2020, was viewed as a prospect with limited NHL potential, having spent the majority of his time in the AHL.

The Sabres, on the other hand, acquired McLeod to bolster their forward depth and add experience to their roster. McLeod's proven track record and relatively affordable contract made him an attractive addition for a team looking to end their playoff drought. Tullio was seen as a depth piece who could potentially contribute at the NHL level in the future.

However, the Oilers' acquisition of Matt Savoie, the ninth overall pick in the 2022 NHL Draft, has the potential to be a game-changer. Savoie, a highly skilled and dynamic forward, had an outstanding junior career, showcasing his offensive prowess and playmaking abilities. While he had limited NHL experience at the time of the trade, his potential was undeniable.

Since joining the Oilers organization, Savoie has exceeded expectations, quickly establishing himself as a key player. His offensive skills have translated seamlessly to the NHL level, and he has become an integral part of Edmonton's top-six forward group. Savoie's speed, agility, and hockey sense have made him a nightmare for opposing defenders, and his ability to create scoring chances has significantly boosted the Oilers' offensive output.

In contrast, Ryan McLeod's performance with the Sabres has been underwhelming. While he has continued to be a reliable penalty killer, his offensive production has declined, and he has struggled to find consistency in Buffalo's lineup. Tullio has remained in the AHL, failing to make a significant impact.

As the 2025-26 season progresses, it is becoming increasingly clear that the Oilers have acquired the most valuable asset in this trade. Matt Savoie's emergence as a star forward has solidified Edmonton's status as a Stanley Cup contender, while Ryan McLeod's struggles in Buffalo have raised questions about the Sabres' decision to trade away a top prospect for a role player. While it is still too early to definitively declare a winner, the Oilers appear to be on the verge of reaping the rewards of their shrewd move.