Vancouver Canucks forward Kiefer Sherwood is generating significant buzz as the trade deadline approaches, sparking debate about his true value on the open market. The central question: Is he worth a first-round pick?
Sherwood, 30, is in the midst of a career year. Acquired by the Canucks as a free agent on July 1, 2024, he has exceeded all expectations. He is currently playing on a two-year deal with an average annual value of $1.5 million that ends in 2025-26. As of late December 2025, Sherwood has 16 goals this season. Beyond his scoring touch, Sherwood brings a tenacious physicality to the ice. During the 2024-25 season, he set a new NHL record with 460 hits.
Several factors contribute to the argument for a significant return for Sherwood. His versatility allows him to slot into various roles within a lineup, providing valuable depth to any contending team. His affordable $1.5 million cap hit makes him an attractive acquisition for teams with limited financial flexibility. Sherwood's work ethic and no-quit style of play quickly made him a fan favorite in Vancouver. He is also a strong penalty killer, averaging over two minutes of penalty kill time per game. Playoff experience is another asset, as Sherwood demonstrated his effectiveness during his time with the Nashville Predators.
However, the case against a first-round pick valuation also has merit. While Sherwood is having a career year, there is the question of whether his offensive output is sustainable. Some analysts believe his recent scoring slump could be a sign of regression, potentially diminishing his trade value. The Canucks' asking price for Sherwood has reportedly been a first-round pick and a good roster player. It remains to be seen whether a team will be willing to meet that price. Some analysts consider the idea of the Canucks getting a first-round pick for Kiefer Sherwood to be unrealistic. As one former NHL goaltender put it, "I just don't see a team giving up a first-round pick for him, but like any good real estate market, he's worth what someone will pay for him".
Ultimately, Sherwood's trade value will be determined by the desperation of contending teams seeking to bolster their rosters for a playoff run. Several teams are rumored to be interested, including the New York Islanders, who have two 2026 first-round picks. The Islanders, after picking first overall in June, surprisingly rank second in the Metropolitan Division.
As the trade deadline draws nearer, the Canucks will need to carefully weigh their options and assess the offers they receive for Sherwood. While a first-round pick may be the ideal scenario, they must also consider the possibility of settling for a package that includes a combination of draft picks and prospects.
