As the NHL season progresses towards the March 6, 2026, trade deadline, speculation is mounting around veteran goaltender Marc-André Fleury and the possibility of him coming out of retirement. Despite hanging up his skates after the 2024-25 season and even playing a final preseason game with the Pittsburgh Penguins, the allure of the "right opportunity" might tempt Fleury back into the league. Two teams frequently mentioned as potential destinations are the Edmonton Oilers and the Montreal Canadiens.

The Oilers' Predicament

The Edmonton Oilers' goaltending situation has been a revolving door of uncertainty. Despite acquiring Tristan Jarry from the Penguins in exchange for Stuart Skinner, Brett Kulak, and a 2029 second-round pick, Jarry was quickly sidelined with a lower-body injury. This has thrust the Oilers into a position where they are relying on backup-caliber goalies. Connor Ingram has been recalled from the AHL to provide support. While Ingram has shown promise in recent games, the Oilers may seek a more proven and experienced netminder for a deep playoff run.

Devan Dubnyk and Mike Rupp of the NHL Network have suggested that the Oilers would be a good fit for Fleury if he wants to win. The Oilers are considered contenders, and Fleury's winning pedigree and leadership could be invaluable. Dubnyk noted that Fleury is the kind of player that teammates instantly rally behind. However, to make room for Fleury, the Oilers would need to make some financial adjustments.

The Canadiens' Sentimental Appeal

For Fleury, a Quebec native, the Montreal Canadiens offer a different kind of appeal: a homecoming. The chance to wear the Canadiens jersey and potentially finish his career in Montreal could be a powerful draw. While the Canadiens may not be as immediate a Stanley Cup contender as the Oilers, the sentimental value of playing in his home province could be a significant factor for Fleury.

The Canadiens have a crowded goaltending situation, with Samuel Montembeault, Jakub Dobes, and the emergence of prospect Jacob Fowler. Montembeault is under contract through the 2026-2027 season, while Dobes recently signed a two-year contract. Fowler's strong play has made the Canadiens' goaltending situation even more complex. Trading Dobes has been suggested as a way to address other needs in the lineup.

Fleury's Decision

Ultimately, the decision rests with Fleury. Several teams have reportedly inquired about his interest in returning. Factors such as the opportunity to play and win, the team's location, and the financial terms would all weigh heavily on his choice. While Fleury's agent has not confirmed any formal talks, the speculation continues to swirl as the trade deadline approaches. The 2025-26 NHL trade deadline is set for March 6, 2026.

Fleury, drafted first overall by the Pittsburgh Penguins in 2003, has had a decorated NHL career, winning three Stanley Cups with the Penguins. He also played for the Vegas Golden Knights, Chicago Blackhawks, and Minnesota Wild. In 2023, he became the fourth goalie in NHL history to play 1,000 games. If Fleury does choose to return, he would bring a wealth of experience and a winning mentality to whichever team he joins.