Montreal – The future of defenseman Kaiden Guhle with the Montreal Canadiens is suddenly clouded with uncertainty, despite being considered a foundational piece of the team's rebuild not long ago. Several factors, including injuries, the emergence of other defensive prospects, and the team's potential trade interests, have converged to raise questions about Guhle's long-term role with the Canadiens.
Guhle, drafted 16th overall in 2020, quickly established himself as a reliable top-four defenseman for Montreal. Known for his defensive prowess, physicality, and leadership qualities, he signed a six-year, $33.3 million contract extension in July 2024, set to begin in the 2025-26 season. The deal carries an average annual value of $5.55 million.
However, injuries have plagued Guhle throughout his NHL career. While he's shown his reliability as a defender when healthy, these injuries have prevented him from playing a full season and consistently contributing to the team. He is currently on injured reserve with a lower-body injury sustained in October, with an estimated return date in late November.
In Guhle's absence, other defensemen have stepped up, showcasing the Canadiens' growing depth on the blue line. Jayden Struble has impressed with his steady play and puck management, while other young defensemen like Arber Xhekaj and recent first-round pick David Reinbacher are also vying for roster spots. The Canadiens also acquired Noah Dobson in the offseason, further solidifying their defensive corps.
The emergence of offensive-minded defenseman Lane Hutson has also changed the dynamic. With Hutson quarterbacking the power play and driving offense from the blue line, Guhle's offensive contributions become less critical. This allows Guhle to focus on his shutdown role, but it also raises the question of whether his skillset is fully optimized within the team's current structure.
Furthermore, the Canadiens are reportedly exploring the trade market to bolster their offense, particularly at the second-line center position. With limited cap space and a desire to add scoring punch, General Manager Kent Hughes may consider moving a defenseman to acquire the needed assets.
Guhle's name has surfaced in trade discussions, although no concrete offers have been reported. While his defensive abilities and contract make him an attractive asset, his injury history and the Canadiens' defensive depth could make him expendable if the right deal presents itself.
Despite the questions surrounding his future, Guhle remains a valuable player for the Canadiens. When healthy, he provides stability, physicality, and leadership on the blue line. His ability to shut down opposing forwards and contribute to the transition game makes him a versatile asset.
Ultimately, Guhle's future with the Canadiens will depend on his ability to stay healthy, the continued development of other defensive prospects, and the team's overall needs as they continue their rebuild. While his spot may not be as secure as it once seemed, Guhle has the opportunity to solidify his role as a key member of the Canadiens' defense if he can overcome the challenges and consistently perform at his best.
