The Toronto Maple Leafs are facing a significant challenge as they head into the 2025-26 season: replacing the offensive production and overall impact of Mitch Marner, who was recently traded to the Vegas Golden Knights. While General Manager Brad Treliving has made several moves to bolster the team's depth, the absence of a top-six forward with Marner's skill set remains a pressing concern. Several potential targets have emerged as possibilities to fill this "Marner-sized hole" on the Maple Leafs' roster.
One intriguing option is a reunion with Nazem Kadri. Kadri, who spent a decade in Toronto, is reportedly open to returning to the Leafs. Coming off a strong season with the Calgary Flames, Kadri could bring invaluable postseason experience and offensive punch to the team. The Maple Leafs have also been linked to Bryan Rust of the Pittsburgh Penguins. Rust has a proven track record of consistent production, with six consecutive 20-plus goal seasons. His experience playing alongside Sidney Crosby and his two Stanley Cups make him an appealing candidate to complement Toronto's core.
Anders Lee from the New York Islanders has also been mentioned as a potential target. Lee is in the final year of his contract and could become a trade chip if the Islanders struggle. His goal-scoring ability and veteran presence could be valuable assets for the Leafs. Evan Rodrigues of the Florida Panthers is another name that has surfaced. With the Panthers facing cap constraints, Rodrigues' affordable contract and playoff experience make him an attractive option.
In addition to these established players, the Maple Leafs may also consider some under-the-radar acquisitions. Matias Maccelli, recently acquired from the Utah Mammoth, could be a potential steal. Despite a disappointing season, Maccelli was previously considered one of the most underrated young talents in the game. Given a fresh start and the opportunity to play alongside Auston Matthews or John Tavares, Maccelli could regain his form and provide a significant offensive boost.
However, Treliving is also exploring trades involving current roster players to acquire a top-six forward. Morgan Rielly's name has surfaced in trade discussions, although his no-move clause complicates matters. Brandon Carlo, recently acquired by the Leafs, has also been mentioned as a potential trade candidate. Trading Carlo could potentially bring in a high-scoring forward like Jason Robertson from the Dallas Stars.
Ultimately, the Maple Leafs' approach to filling the void left by Marner will depend on a variety of factors, including cap space, asset availability, and the willingness of other teams to make a deal. Treliving has already shown a willingness to be aggressive in reshaping the roster, and further moves are expected as the team aims to build a more balanced and competitive lineup around Auston Matthews and company. The coming weeks will be crucial in determining who the Maple Leafs target to fill that "Marner-sized hole" and how they plan to address their need for a top-six forward.
