Shivam Dube's recent performance in the Asia Cup 2025 opener against the UAE has sparked both praise and scrutiny, particularly regarding his role as India's third seamer. While Dube impressed with a career-best figure of 3/4, helping India restrict the UAE to a mere 57 runs, some critics have questioned the significance of this performance, suggesting that any bowler could have achieved similar results against a weaker opponent.

Former India opener Sadagopan Ramesh believes that the all-rounder's inclusion as the third pacer indicates a concerning trend. However, former India spinner Amit Mishra lauded Dube's performance, emphasizing that the team should allow him to bowl three to four overs in every game to develop him as a proper all-rounder. Mishra acknowledged Dube's batting prowess and highlighted the added advantage of his left-handedness. He believes Dube can evolve into a valuable all-rounder for the Indian team with consistent backing.

Dube himself has credited India's bowling coach, Morne Morkel, for his improved bowling performance. Morkel has been working with Dube since the England series, advising him to bowl a line slightly outside off-stump, develop a slower delivery, and tweak his run-up. Dube acknowledged that these adjustments have enhanced his bowling and increased his pace. He has been focused on improving his fitness and expanding his range of shots to counter bowlers targeting him with short balls.

Despite the criticisms, Dube's performance against the UAE showcased his potential as a genuine all-rounder. He played a crucial role in India's nine-wicket victory, demonstrating that his bowling can be just as effective as his power-hitting. Dube's ability to contribute with both bat and ball provides India with valuable flexibility and depth in their lineup. His inclusion allows the team to have six genuine bowling options and extends the batting order.

Dube, however, downplays any comparisons to Hardik Pandya, emphasizing that he learns a lot from the experienced all-rounder. He sees Pandya as a brother and focuses on absorbing as much knowledge as possible from him. When questioned about the match against Pakistan, Dube stated that he approaches every game with the same mindset, following the instructions of his coach, Gautam Gambhir. He recognizes that playing for India is an opportunity to achieve great things for the country.

Morne Morkel has emphasized Dube's importance in the team's composition, viewing him as a valuable option who can deliver crucial overs when conditions are favorable. This approach allows India tactical flexibility and depth. By utilizing Dube's bowling effectively, India can optimize the use of their key bowlers like Jasprit Bumrah and Kuldeep Yadav.

While some may dismiss Dube's success against the UAE, his performance reflects his dedication to improving his all-round skills. With guidance from the coaching staff and a focus on continuous improvement, Dube has the potential to solidify his place as a valuable asset to the Indian team.