Nicholas Robertson, drafted 53rd overall in 2019, has long been a topic of discussion among Toronto Maple Leafs fans, celebrated for his junior hockey performances and glimpses of NHL potential. However, the 24-year-old winger finds himself at a crucial juncture in his career with the team. After a series of injuries, inconsistent performances, and difficulty securing a consistent role, his future with the Maple Leafs is uncertain.

Robertson signed a one-year, $1.825 million contract with the Maple Leafs on August 2, 2025, to avoid arbitration. However, this deal doesn't guarantee him a spot on the roster. New head coach Craig Berube has made it clear that competition for roster spots will be intense, placing Robertson under pressure to prove his worth during training camp.

Berube's emphasis on hard work, physicality, and all-around contribution highlights the challenge for Robertson, who is known more for his offensive skills. The coach's direct approach means Robertson must demonstrate his value in all aspects of the game to earn a place in the lineup.

The Maple Leafs have bolstered their forward depth by acquiring Mattias Maccelli, Nicolas Roy, Dakota Joshua, and Michael Pezzetta, intensifying the competition for roster spots. DailyFaceoff projections don't currently include Robertson in the top four lines, reflecting the uphill battle he faces.

TSN insider Chris Johnston has reported that the Maple Leafs are open to trading Robertson. This isn't a new development, as Robertson requested a trade last summer due to dissatisfaction with his opportunities in Toronto. While he made the NHL roster out of camp, he struggled to maintain a strong presence in the lineup and saw limited playoff action.

The Maple Leafs are looking for additional assets in return for Robertson, aiming to replenish their prospect pool. They are open to a young player or a draft pick that could be used in future trades.

Robertson's offensive capabilities are evident. Last season, he scored 15 goals and contributed seven assists in 69 games. However, concerns about his defensive game have often led to him being a healthy scratch. Despite his skill and potential, Robertson hasn't consistently fit into the Maple Leafs' system.

For Robertson, the path forward involves a strong training camp performance to demonstrate his commitment and ability to contribute to the team's overall game. Otherwise, the Maple Leafs may decide that his future lies elsewhere, and he may soon be wearing a different uniform.