The Toronto Maple Leafs' quest to find a consistent right-winger to play alongside Auston Matthews continues to be a major storyline early in the 2025-26 NHL season. Following the departure of Mitch Marner in a sign-and-trade to the Vegas Golden Knights, the Leafs have struggled to find a suitable replacement to complement Matthews and Matthew Knies on the top line.
Head coach Craig Berube has been experimenting with various options, but none have solidified the role. Matias Maccelli, acquired in a trade, was given an initial look but hasn't consistently produced the desired results. Rookie Easton Cowan has also had a brief stint on the top line, and Max Domi, who has played with Matthews in the past, has been tried as well. However, Berube admitted he is growing "tired" of the situation, hinting that a more permanent solution needs to be found quickly.
The lack of a consistent right-winger has contributed to the Maple Leafs' sluggish start to the season, with a record of 3-3-1. The top line has struggled to generate sustained offensive zone pressure, leading to frustration for both the coaching staff and the players. John Tavares noted that the team is playing "sloppy" and needs to manage the game better.
In response to the ongoing struggles, Berube is considering a "nuclear option" by moving William Nylander to the top line. Nylander, who is currently leading the team in points, has had some shifts with Matthews and Knies, showing flashes of potential. However, this would mean weakening the second line, where Nylander has primarily played alongside Tavares. Berube acknowledged the desire for offensive balance throughout the lineup but recognizes the urgency for results.
Some hockey analysts suggest that the Maple Leafs should explore external options via trade. Alex Tuch of the Buffalo Sabres and Rickard Rakell of the Pittsburgh Penguins have been mentioned as potential targets. Another option could be Nazem Kadri of the Calgary Flames, who previously played for the Leafs.
The Maple Leafs' struggles to find a suitable right-winger for Auston Matthews highlight the challenges of replacing a star player like Mitch Marner. While internal options remain, the team may need to consider a significant move to unlock the full potential of their star center and ignite their offense. The pressure is mounting on General Manager Brad Treliving to find a solution that can propel the Maple Leafs to a deeper playoff run.
